Noah Smith
| About | Noah Smith is an economist and former Bloomberg Opinion columnist who now writes the widely read Noahpinion newsletter, covering economics, technology, and the political economy of growth and abundance. |
|---|
Noah Smith
Economist and writer behind the Noahpinion Substack, and one of the steadier sources in Kyle’s “build” and venture-economics reading. His essay The Build-Nothing Country is the mechanistic counterpart to Marc Andreessen’s It’s Time To Build: where Andreessen diagnoses a failure of will, Smith diagnoses a broken permitting / land-use / development system — “money is not physical stuff” — exploited by entrenched local interests (the Second Avenue Subway as the world’s most expensive subway line, NIMBY opposition to housing and green energy, homeowners who raise their paper wealth by restricting local supply). Kyle reads the two essays as direct intellectual descendants in his Techno-Optimism thread.
Smith also anchors part of What Is An Investor. Kyle leans on his “Will VC produce fewer home runs in the future?” piece — the “next Facebook” question — and on Smith’s application of Frank Knight’s Knightian Uncertainty to explain why outsized Venture Capital returns are getting rarer as the market matures.
Where this appears
- The Build-Nothing Country — his diagnosis that America can’t build housing, transit, or green energy because of broken permitting and local incentives, not lack of money.
- It’s Time To Build — listed as the direct intellectual ancestor; Smith’s essay is its more mechanistic descendant.
- What Is An Investor / What Is An Investor - Research — his “fewer home runs” / Knightian-uncertainty argument on declining VC returns.
- It’s Time To Build… But Build What - Research — appears in the techno-optimism reading notes.
- Knightian Uncertainty / Frank Knight — the uncertainty distinction Smith invokes for venture.
- Techno-Optimism / Venture Capital — the broader threads his writing feeds.
- Does Anything I Write Matter Anymore? — Smith’s reflection on punditry’s declining leverage under populism, Substack monetization, and AI content saturation.
- I Have Never Been Working Class — Smith’s argument that American class is about future earning potential, not present-day snapshot, applied to critique PMC socialism and manufactured “working class” champions.
- Stop Screeching About Immigration, And Get Smart About It — his case for skilled, legal immigration as the antidote to America’s fertility crisis.
- The American Age Was The Human Age — his 250th-anniversary essay on American sclerosis, declining patriotism, and the looming end of “the human age” under AI.
- The American Suburbs Are Better Than You Think — his evidence-based defense of suburbia against the urbanist critique on commutes and loneliness.
- Slopulism Is Taking Over America — author; coins “slopulism” for policy that inverts its own goal.
- Roundup #87 — Technology BAD!! (Noahpinion) — five-item roundup covering AI alignment (obedience vs. benevolence), smartphone-vs-TV social isolation debate, leftist antisemitism, Acemoglu’s automation-repression theory, and America missing the Electric Revolution.
- How We Can Beat China (Noahpinion) — Smith recalibrates his Biden-era Cold War 2 strategy: Trump has made the allied-bloc approach impossible by degrading key alliances; “beating China” should now mean helping smaller democracies resist Chinese domination while waiting for China’s own internal contradictions to do the heavy lifting.
- India Is Quietly Doing Great (Noahpinion) — Nov 2026: India is at roughly the GDP/HDI level China occupied in the late 2000s and is replicating — without fanfare — the same poverty-escaping, infrastructure-building growth trajectory China ran. Extreme poverty largely conquered; World Bank credits strong consumption growth (especially female employment) and expanded social transfers; infrastructure spending up 4–8× since pre-pandemic. Electronics exports up 90% YoY. Key remaining risks: rural education, female underemployment, weak private/FDI investment.
- Why I’m Becoming a China Bear (Noahpinion) — Nov 2026 (companion piece, 4 days earlier): Smith revises his long-held China bull position. Three reasons, ranked: AI will disrupt everything and China’s system is optimized for the ending era; Xi’s manufacturing strategy is running out of demand tailwinds as the property boom ends; political deterioration under Xi is turning the country inward. China is “incredibly good at deploying technology after others have done the hard work” — which is least valuable in a moment of rapid foundational disruption.
- Bumbition (Noahpinion) — Nov 2026: Smith coins “bumbition” (bum + ambition) for people who drift without fixed goals until a compelling opportunity appears, then work furiously. Argues the AI age makes bumbition more valuable because AI hill-climbs; the human task is setting the right goals, which requires the exploration and curiosity the “bum” phase builds.
- I’m Feeling More Optimistic About American Politics (Noahpinion) — Nov 2026: After the 2026 midterms, Smith revises his pessimism. The blue wave was led by liberals/moderates, not the DSA faction; purple-state voters endorsed centrist ballot measures; Jon Ossoff emerges as a credible 2028 contender; and bipartisan movement on the “Build-Nothing” problem is starting. (Partial capture — paywalled.)
What links here
- Competitive Moats
- Having a Conversation With Yourself: 2024
- It's Time To Build... But Build What?
- Oh Say, What is Truth?
- The Axis of Building
- At Least Five Interesting Things for the Middle of Your Week (#8)
- \"You Can See Everything\" and the nature of liars
- Abundance
- AI Is Already in Dangerous Hands
- AI Keeps Stubbornly Refusing to Take Our Jobs
- AI's Big Messaging Pivot
- Biden Is Right That We Need to Raise Taxes (Noahpinion)
- Blindsight
- Bumbition (Noahpinion)
- Can a Million AI Agents Create Superintelligence?
- Capital Gains
- China
- City Building
- Degrowth
- Does Anything I Write Matter Anymore?
- Economic Growth
- France and the limits of liberalism
- Generative AI: Autocomplete for Everything
- How To Build If… It's Time To Build?
- How We Can Beat China (Noahpinion)
- I Have Never Been Working Class
- I'm Feeling More Optimistic About American Politics (Noahpinion)
- Immigration
- Inflation Reduction Act
- It's Time To Build
- John Maynard Keynes
- Knightian Uncertainty
- Marc Andreessen
- Middleclass
- Niall Ferguson and Tyler Cowen — AIpocalypse Now
- NIMBY
- Patriotism
- Productivity
- Ramez Naam
- Republic of Letters
- Robin Hanson
- Roundup #87 — Technology BAD!! (Noahpinion)
- Slopulism
- Slopulism Is Taking Over America
- Stop Screeching About Immigration, And Get Smart About It
- Suburban Sprawl
- Techno-Optimism
- The AI Hater's Manifesto
- The American Age Was The Human Age
- The American Suburbs Are Better Than You Think
- The Build-Nothing Country
- The China Fetish Is Getting to Be a Bit Much
- The Dangerous Ideology Behind the AI Warnings
- The Hollowing Out of the Middle Class
- The internet breaks
- Two Missing Pieces in the AI Safety Discussion
- Tyler Cowen
- Vitalik Buterin
- What Just Happened With the Pacing AI Debate (TBPN)
- What the AI Boom Is Doing for Americans
- Where's the \"Intelligence Explosion\"? (Ramez Naam, Noahpinion)
- Why are we ruled by barbarians?
- Will VC produce fewer home runs in the future?
- You Are What You Consume