Capital Gains
Capital Gains
The profit realized on the sale of an asset held for investment, taxed differently depending on the holding period and applicable rules.
Mechanics (real estate context)
From Real Estate Ranger’s thread: short-term gains (held under a year) are taxed at ordinary income rates; long-term gains (held over a year) are taxed at approximately 15–28%. Depreciation recapture adds complexity — accumulated depreciation deductions create a separate tax liability at a 25% recapture rate when the property is sold, and this can exceed the apparent capital gain. A 1031 Exchange defers both capital gains and recapture by rolling the tax basis forward.
Policy debate
Noah Smith on Biden’s FY2025 tax proposals: taxing capital gains at the same rate as ordinary income is defensible because “people just don’t change their behavior much in order to try to avoid capital gains taxes” (citing Goldman Sachs analysis via John Authers). The bigger prize is eliminating step-up basis — the rule by which inheriting an appreciated asset “washes the tax liability away forever” — which Smith calls “a pure loophole.” The Biden proposal for an unrealized-gains accrual tax gets more skepticism: taxing paper gains on illiquid startup stock creates liquidity problems and would hurt early-stage companies.