I'm Feeling More Optimistic About American Politics (Noahpinion)
| Author | Noah Smith |
|---|---|
| Published | November 14, 2026 |
| Format | Article |
| Original | Read the original |
After the 2026 midterms, Smith revises his pessimism: Democrats won big but it was liberals — not the DSA/leftist faction — who led the charge, purple-state voters endorsed centrist ballot measures alongside Democratic candidates, and smart policy is starting to win over culture wars.
I’m Feeling More Optimistic About American Politics (Noahpinion)
[PARTIAL] — Paywalled Substack article. The email capture contains the full “Liberals, not leftists” section and the opening of “Smart policy is starting to win,” but cuts off before Smith’s third positive trend (corruption accountability). The key claims and quotes below are drawn entirely from the available text.
Key claims
- Smith identifies three broad positive trends from the 2026 midterms, but is explicit that his optimism is not just because Democrats won — it’s about how they won and what they’re likely to do with the victory.
- The DSA/leftist faction (rooted in the Bernie insurgency and radicalized by Palestine activism) did not lead the Democratic wave as Smith had feared in summer 2026. High-profile DSA-faction candidates performed significantly worse than normie Democratic counterparts, and Francesca Hong was defeated in the primary race just days after Smith wrote that leftists were “who the Democrats are now.”
- Voters who powered the blue wave also endorsed centrist ballot measures: photo ID for voting in multiple states, state income tax caps in Iowa and North Carolina, and anti-affirmative action measures in some blue states. Moderates and independents drove Democratic gains everywhere.
- The sheer scale of the Democratic victory means marginal wins in purple states push leadership to moderates (Hakeem Jeffries, Chuck Schumer), structurally disempowering the DSA faction. This is driving DSA commentators “apoplectic with rage.”
- Jon Ossoff emerged as the most prominent potential 2028 presidential contender after a massive midterm victory. Leftist commentators are already targeting him (Ken Klippenstein asking “why does Schumer love Ossoff?” as a smear). With AOC’s enthusiasm dimmed, leftists have no obvious replacement candidate.
- America’s “Build-Nothing” problem — the progressive policies that made it prohibitively difficult to build housing, roads, trains, and power stations across much of the country — is showing early signs of bipartisan movement. (Full argument cut off by paywall.)
- Smith notes an indefinable cultural “vibe shift”: people are less ashamed to express support for Barack Obama-style mainstream liberalism, and liberal influencers are more willing to push back on leftist shouters.
Notable quotes
“Partisanship is a helluva drug. When your preferred party is in power, the sun seems to shine a little brighter, the birds sing a little more sweetly, and there’s a spring in your step as you walk past the homeless encampments and sterile single-family-home-only neighborhoods of your American city.”
“Democrats have spent their political capital moving to the left…[They are selecting] candidates who are so far to the left that they end up frightening and/or offending many voters, and then basically daring people to keep voting for the Republicans… This, increasingly, is who the Democrats are now.” — Smith writing in summer 2026, a view he now revises
“Voters in North Carolina elected a Democratic senator…giving former governor Roy Cooper an overwhelming win. At the same time, they approved three [Republican] measures…[including] a constitutional requirement for a levy limit on property taxes…In Wisconsin, Democrat David Crowley won the gubernatorial election…Those same voters approved an initiative…to ban affirmative action in state institutions…Iowa voted Democratic for Senate and governor while amending their constitution to make it substantially harder to raise state income taxes.” — Washington Post on the split-ticket reality
“I have come to the conclusion that Hakeem Jeffries is the most serious threat to the progressive agenda in the country, more so than Trump himself, and that any progressive not loudly, actively opposing Jeffries is actively betraying their movement.” — Nathan J. Robinson on X
“What’s the use of kicking out the Republicans, if the Democrats are just going to decide that ‘open space’ and historic gas stations are more important than giving the middle class a place to live and power for their homes?” — Smith on the Build-Nothing problem that may now be getting addressed
How it connects
- Noah Smith — author
- Democratic Party — primary subject; the battle between its liberal and leftist factions
- Political Polarization — the broader dysfunction Smith has been pessimistic about for years
- Populism — the “MAGA on the left” parallel Smith draws between DSA and right-wing populism
- Jon Ossoff — the centrist 2028 frontrunner emerging from the midterms
- Democracy — Smith’s broader concern about liberal democracy’s health in America
- Why I’m Becoming a China Bear (Noahpinion) — same week’s piece; both reflect a moment of recalibration in Smith’s worldview
- India Is Quietly Doing Great (Noahpinion) — another Nov 2026 Noahpinion piece showing a broadly reoptimistic turn