Skip to content
kwharrison13.comEssays, books and notes by Kyle Harrison

Note-taking

From kwharrison13.com · Concept

Note-taking

A central practice in Kyle’s Open Source Knowledge thinking and the engine behind this wiki itself. The anchoring book is How To Take Smart Notes by Sonke Ahrens, whose Zettelkasten slip-box reframes note-taking away from accumulation toward transformation: “the slip-box does not put the learner in the centre… Learning, thinking and writing should not be about accumulating knowledge, but about becoming a different person with a different way of thinking.” Kyle folds this into a Culture of Questions in his Open-Source Knowledge research, alongside Andy Matuschak’s “Why Books Don’t Work.”

The sharpest case for it comes from The Collector’s Fallacy by Christian Tietze: reading without taking notes is “a waste of time in the long run,” because the information stays in short-term memory and is forgotten, while taking notes “permanently integrates the text’s information into your own knowledge system, making it available forever.” Tietze’s remedy — Research, Read, Assimilate; rinse and repeat — frames note-taking as the assimilation step that turns mere collection into actual knowing. Umberto Eco supplies the negative version (in How to Write a Thesis): photocopying a text gives “the illusion of having read the text already.”

The Notetaking Cold War by Dan Shipper reframes the whole subject as “philosophy in action”: the Tiago Forte-vs-Conor White-Sullivan debate over how to organize notes (actionable PARA hierarchy vs. infinitely-flexible bidirectional links) maps onto a two-thousand-year-old split between Essentialists (truth as a relationship between statement and reality) and Pragmatists (truth as what works). A note, Shipper argues, is a box you can stick anything into — information whose use is unpredictable — which is exactly why it resists organization. David Perell adds the social dimension in his Twitter workshop: “note-taking is a conversation with your past self.” The practice also surfaces historically in Saints — No Unhallowed Hand, where Kyle flags the discipline of Eliza R. Snow’s careful minute-keeping and “home literature.” Kyle threads this whole cluster — note-taking, Knowledge Management, Personal Knowledge Management — into the conceptual ancestry of his own LLM wiki.

Context: Note-taking as a knowledge-work discipline saw a software-driven revival in the late 2010s — Roam Research, Obsidian, Notion — popularizing networked-thought tools and methods like Zettelkasten and “building a second brain.”

Saved tweets

Readwise onboarding — September 9th, 2021

  • Readwise onboarding
    • Craft Docs
    • Mem.ai
    • Bear

Where this appears

Link Kyle saved to this topic in his April 30th, 2020 Roam “Quick Capture” log.

Saved from Roam

Curated by Kyle Harrison. Organized by Claude. Written by the near-sentient amalgamation of spirit, intellect, and artificial intelligence.