Kyle Harrison
← Bookshelf

The Smartest Kids in the World

Amanda Ripley
Read 2017

Key Takeaways

  • Education as a deliberate national investment. With no natural resources, Korea “cultivated its people instead, turning education into currency” — and education functioned “like an anti-poverty vaccine,” making family background less and less relevant to a child’s life chances over time.
  • Teacher quality is the ceiling. “The quality of an education system cannot exceed the quality of its teachers” (Teacher Celebrities). Making the profession harder to enter makes it more attractive and more respected: Finnish students esteemed faculty precisely because of the academic rigor teachers endured to qualify.
  • Rigor over innate talent. Korean students assumed performance was a product of hard work, not God-given talent, and refused shortcuts — especially in math, which Ripley calls “rigor distilled,” the discipline that embeds higher-order habits of reasoning and pattern-detection.
  • Parents as coaches, not cheerleaders. Across every country, kids read better when parents read to them daily as young children and discussed books, movies, and current affairs with them as teens. The best parents “teach them good habits and give them autonomy… they want their children to fail while they are still children.”
  • School choice needs real information. A true education market only disciplines schools if parents can see “the rigor of a school and the quality of its teachers, not just the aesthetics of the building or the ethnicity of the students” — and that useful information is “shamefully hard to find.”
  • Universal discontent. In every country, people complained about their schools — “a universal truth and a strangely reassuring one.” Educating all kids to high levels is hard, and every system still has work to do.

Connections

No cross-book interconnections identified yet.

Highlights

  • “[Korea] had no natural resources, so it cultivated its people instead, turning education into currency.”
  • “Education acted like an anti-poverty vaccine in Korea, rendering family background less and less relevant to kids’ life chances over time.”
  • “The quality of an education system cannot exceed the quality of its teachers.” — #Teacher Celebrities
  • “Koreans understood that mastering difficult academic content was important. They didn’t take shortcuts, especially in math. They assumed that performance was mostly a product of hard work — not God-given talent.”
  • “More than any other subject, math is rigor distilled. Mastering the language of logic helps to embed higher-order habits in kids minds: the ability to reason, for example, to detect patterns and to make informed guesses. Those kinds of skills had rising value in a world in which information was cheap and messy.”
  • “Once it became harder to be a teacher, it could also become more attractive. More people might want to do it, and fewer established teachers might leave the profession.”
  • “My Finnish school fostered a great deal of respect for the institution and faculty in the students. This can be partly explained by the academic rigors that teachers had to endure in their journeys to becoming educators. The students were well aware of how accomplished their teachers were.”
  • “When children were young, parents who read to them every day or almost every day had kids who performed much better in reading, all around the world, by the time they were fifteen.”
  • “All over the world, parents who discussed movies, books, and current affairs with their kids had teenagers who performed better in reading.”
  • “Everywhere I went, in every country, people complained about their education system. It was a universal truth and a strangely reassuring one. No one was content, and rightly so. Educating all kids to high levels was hard, and every country — every one — still had work to do.”
  • “I wondered what would happen in a true free market in which parents had real insight into the rigor of a school and the quality of its teachers, not just the aesthetics of the building or the ethnicity of the students. Some U.S. education reformers and politicians were convinced that more competition would lead to just this kind of scenario, pushing schools to get better results, or shut down.”
  • “In most countries, most parents have some choice as to where to send their children to school. It is a very hard choice, however, and useful information is shamefully hard to find.”
  • “Parents who view themselves as educational coaches tend to read to their children every day when they are small; when their children get older, they talk with them about their days and about the news around the world. They let their children make mistakes and then get right back to work. They teach them good habits and give them autonomy. They are teachers, too, in other words, and they believe in rigor. They want their children to fail while they are still children. They know that those lessons — about hard work, persistence, integrity, and consequences — will serve a child for decades to come.”