The Progress of Knowledge Has Led to a Regression of Thought (Edgar Morin)
| Author | Edgar Morin |
|---|---|
| Published | January 22, 2024 |
| Format | Essay |
| Original | Read the original |
Wars, ecological crisis and creeping authoritarianism make this “midnight in the century,” and the deepest cause is that knowledge split into separated disciplines has blinded thought to complexity; the response must be a spiritual resistance grounded in fellowship, life and love.
The Progress of Knowledge Has Led to a Regression of Thought (Edgar Morin)
Key claims
- Midnight in the century. Morin borrows the title of Victor Serge’s 1939 novel. Two wars are underway: Ukraine, which has pushed the global South toward autonomy from the West and tightened “a Russia-China bloc,” and the Middle East after Hamas’s October 7, 2023 massacre and Israel’s bombing of Gaza, which has “reawakened the dormant Palestinian issue.”
- Polycrisis. The wars worsen a “conjunction of crises” driven by antagonism among three empires (the United States, Russia, China): “ecological, economic, political, social, civilizational—and it is escalating.”
- Neo-totalitarian drift. Democracy is in crisis on every continent; authoritarian regimes with “computerized control over populations and individuals” tend toward “societies of submission that could be called neo-totalitarian.” Globalization “has created no solidarity.”
- Progress produces regression. Scientific and technical progress enabled the “scientific organization” of Auschwitz, the atomic bomb, deadlier wars and, driven by profit, the planetary ecological crisis.
- Blind thought. Knowledge advancing “through the multiplication and mutual separation of disciplines” and dominated by calculation “is unable to conceive the complexity of reality,” which brings back “dogmatisms and fanaticisms” and a crisis of morality.
- An anthropological crisis without hope. The polycrisis is “the crisis of humanity failing to become Humanity.” It may be too late for a change of course, so we must move to Resistance “with or without hope,” as the French did under occupation from 1940.
- What resistance means. First “of the spirit”: resisting lies “asserted as truth,” collective intoxication, collective blame of a people, hatred and contempt, and seeking to understand complexity, verify information and accept uncertainty. Then “oases” of agroecological communities and solidarity networks, and educating the young for Eros against Polemos and Thanatos.
Notable quotes
“Prodigious technological and scientific progress in all areas is the cause of the worst regressions of our century.”
“Though difficult to conceive, we must realize that the progress of knowledge, through the multiplication and mutual separation of disciplines, has caused a regression of thought, which in fact has become blind.”
“The polycrisis we are experiencing across the planet is an anthropological crisis: it is the crisis of humanity failing to become Humanity.”
“We do not know if the global situation is only desperate [désespérante] or truly hopeless [désespérée].”
“The first and fundamental resistance is that of the spirit. It requires resisting the intimidation of every lie asserted as truth, the contagion of every collective intoxication.”
“It prescribes the concern to understand the complexity of problems and phenomena rather than yielding to a partial or unilateral vision. It requires research, verification of information, and acceptance of uncertainties.”
“The tunnels are not endless, the probable is not the certain, and the unexpected is always possible.”
How it connects
- Complexity · Complexity Theory — the column’s core diagnosis is that knowledge split into disciplines “is unable to conceive the complexity of reality.”
- Between Psyche and Cyborg — Jung vs Borg (The Marginalian) — a parallel 2024 argument that information has outrun understanding.