Between Psyche and Cyborg — Jung vs Borg (The Marginalian)
| Author | Maria Popova |
|---|---|
| Published | March 29, 2024 |
| Format | Article |
| Original | Read the original |
Just as Rachel Carson woke us to the outer ecology, we need an awakening to the inner “ecology of mind” that digital capitalism and Silicon Valley’s posthumanism are degrading, and Carl Jung’s depth psychology is the map back to the “deeply human.”
Between Psyche and Cyborg — Jung vs Borg (The Marginalian)
Full headline: “Between Psyche and Cyborg: Carl Jung’s Legacy and the Countercultural Courage to Reclaim the Deeply Human in a Posthuman Age.”
Key claims
- Posthumanism as a cult. Popova frames today’s “technocratic cult of posthumanism” as the heir of Samuel Butler’s warning about humanity dehumanized by its machines. Slater argues it has produced “a widening divide between fabrication and authenticity, a loss of more self-aware and soulful modes of living, and an increase in anxiety and depression.”
- The Silent Spring analogy. Industrial capitalism commodified ecosystems; digital capitalism has “turned our habits of mind into the earth’s most valuable commodity.” Carson pioneered holistic ecology and her contemporary Jung pioneered holistic psychology.
- Information without understanding. “Abundant information has furthered scientific knowledge but not human understanding”; attention, motivation, identity, self-image and the capacity to reason and imagine are all affected, and the suffering itself “has been given over to technological solutions, resulting in a vicious cycle.”
- Vertical vs. horizontal. The “deeply human” anchors a vertical axis of inner understanding, which “an almost exclusive dedication to a horizontal axis of data gathering” now threatens, leaving “a world drowning in information and thirsting for understanding.”
- Dissociation and the denial of death. Popova traces Western dichotomies (past/future, inner/outer, matter/spirit) to dissociation from the body, culminating in Silicon Valley’s dreams of “downloading the mind onto disembodied machines and reducing the soul to a datum.”
- Jung’s counterpoint. Jung shows the psyche is self-regulating and organized by archetypal forms that “we may choose to overlook but cannot ultimately dismiss”; even after embracing reason and science, non-rational impulses and religious ideas keep shaping us unconsciously.
- Co-creation and a reanimated world. “Godlike power necessitates godlike responsibility.” Slater calls for a “co-creation,” a partnership between innovation, self-knowledge and a fitting cosmology, in which spirit and matter are “recognized as mutually dependent.”
- Emotions as intelligence. Drawing on Martha Nussbaum (emotions are “parts… of this creature’s reasoning itself”), Slater treats trust in emotion as the door to the deeply human and possibly “the world’s way of speaking to us.”
- The wider canon. Slater reads Jung through Hannah Arendt, William James, Yuval Harari and Oliver Sacks; Popova pairs the book with Iain McGilchrist, James Bridle and Teilhard de Chardin.
Notable quotes
“Abundant information has furthered scientific knowledge but not human understanding. It has instead left us dazed, confused, and disoriented.” — Glen Slater
“The technosphere now overlays the ecosphere and we cannot help but inhale its post-industrial gases. Virtuality has begun to displace reality, making the ground of human existence hard to discern…” — Slater
“This is leading to a world drowning in information and thirsting for understanding.” — Slater
“Jung pointedly demonstrates that even as we have embraced reason and science, the archetypal world of non-rational impulses and religious ideas have continued to unconsciously influence our thoughts and actions.” — Slater
“Godlike power necessitates godlike responsibility. This begins with self-awareness, which is rooted in a sober consideration of the human psyche, the most critical part of which is shedding light on the shadow side of our willful pursuits…” — Slater
“A reanimated world is one in which spirit and matter are not just equally regarded but recognized as mutually dependent.” — Slater
“Posthumanism brightens the ego-light, the light of the intellect and will that blankets the light of natural consciousness the wise ape presents to us.” — Slater
How it connects
- Carl Jung · Transhumanism — Slater’s “posthumanism” is the transhumanist project seen from the psyche’s side.
- The Progress of Knowledge Has Led to a Regression of Thought (Edgar Morin) — the same year, a parallel argument that knowledge has outrun understanding.
- Iain McGilchrist · Hannah Arendt — named as companions to the book.
- Maria Popova.