The Great Blue Frontier
| Author | Will O'Brien and Packy McCormick |
|---|---|
| Published | April 23, 2026 |
| Format | Article |
| Original | Read the original |
America once dreamed of settling the ocean as seriously as the Moon, gave up after 1969, and can now industrialize it, because cheap autonomous fleets built on four converging technology curves finally collapse the cost of persistent work at sea.
The Great Blue Frontier
O’Brien is co-founder and President of Ulysses, an ocean robotics company; the essay ran after Ulysses raised $46M in a round led by a16z American Dynamism (McCormick notes his fund is not an investor). Kyle found it on 2026-11-18 when O’Brien pointed Palmer Luckey to it in reply to a clip of Luckey predicting permanent megastructures at sea (see Yes - The Great Blue… (tweet) and Palmer Luckey says we’ll soon… (tweet)).
Key claims
- The ocean was once a twin frontier to space. In the 1960s Kennedy nearly doubled federal oceanography spending and sent Congress a ten-year, $2 billion plan; Cousteau’s Conshelf habitats and the Navy’s SEALAB program put people on the seabed; by the late 1960s more than 60 underwater habitats existed. GM’s Futurama II at the 1964 World’s Fair showed 26 million visitors a sub-oceanic resort beside a lunar base.
- The dream died in about five years. SEALAB was suspended after aquanaut Berry Cannon died in February 1969 from an empty CO₂ scrubber, five months before Apollo 11. The Navy turned to Vietnam, and Cousteau himself pivoted from exploration to protection, founding the Cousteau Society in 1973. The authors credit the regulations that followed as individually important but cumulatively a retreat.
- An unindustrialized ocean is a lawless one, not a pristine one. Three of four industrial fishing vessels are invisible to public tracking (per a 2024 Nature study); two-thirds of the ocean is outside any national jurisdiction; only 27% of the ocean floor is mapped with modern sonar (much of it coarse), against 100% of Mars’s surface. “Paper parks” cover about 8% of the ocean with little enforcement.
- Frontiers industrialize in four stages: discovery, expedition, access breakthrough, industrialization. The railroad did it for the American West and reusable rockets for space. The ocean already has a $2.6 trillion pre-industrial economy (shipping, oil, fishing, cables, ports), an order of magnitude larger than the space economy when SpaceX was founded, and still never got its “railroad.”
- The “Ocean Tax” is why. Corrosion, biofouling, pressure (one atmosphere per ten meters), storms and a communications desert where GPS fails and radio dies within about 20 meters tax every operation, and a cottage maritime supply chain taxes it a second time.
- The answer looks more like Starlink than a railroad: fleets of cheap, autonomous, surface-plus-subsea vehicles that can act, not just sense. The global AUV market makes about 1,000 vehicles a year at $500k to $5M each; Ulysses claims $50,000 units, with data-center-class GPUs aboard so vehicles can decide for themselves.
- “Why now” is curve convergence, 2020 to 2025. Starlink Maritime (roughly $250 a month for 100+ Mbps versus $5,000+ before), battery density doubling to 300+ Wh/kg with pack costs falling from $1,191 to $115 per kWh, edge AI compute, and drone/EV/consumer supply chains that commoditized motors and sensors. The term “Curve Convergence” is borrowed from McCormick’s earlier Cable Caballero.
- Demand arrives from independent directions at once: AI-driven subsea cable builds (99% of intercontinental internet traffic runs over them, with essentially no persistent surveillance), critical minerals on the seafloor, and defense. The governing metric they propose is the cost of active operation per square kilometer per month, the ocean’s analogue to $/kg to orbit.
- Industrialization and conservation are complements. The closing case study is Russ George’s 2012 iron-fertilization experiment off Haida Gwaii, which produced a plankton bloom visible from space and was followed by a record salmon run, yet could never be verified because nothing was there to measure it. Persistent infrastructure provides the sense-intervene-measure loop; O’Brien expects permanent ocean habitats to follow (“seasteading, seriously: I think it could actually work in the next decade”).
Notable quotes
“We know less of the oceans at our feet, where we came from, than we do of the sky above our heads.” — John F. Kennedy, 1963, as quoted in the essay
“Berry Cannon was dead. And with him died America’s plans to conquer the ocean.”
“To industrialize a frontier means to transform it from a place with industries in it, exploring and opportunistically extracting, to a place built to support industries persistently and economically, at scale.”
“An industrialized frontier is a platform, not a series of projects. Each new piece of infrastructure makes the next one cheaper and unlocks activities that weren’t possible before. An industrialized frontier compounds.”
“A pre-industrial ocean doesn’t mean an untouched ocean; it just means that the pirates are the ones doing the touching.”
“We call it the Ocean Tax: the compounding cost the sea, and the industry that grew around it, extracts from anyone who tries to do anything in it.”
“Every great era of advancement has corresponded to an active frontier… When there is somewhere new to go, the best minds build toward it. When there isn’t, that energy turns inward. It optimizes. It litigates.”
How it connects
- Palmer Luckey — the reason Kyle saved it: O’Brien recommended it to Luckey under a clip of Luckey saying ocean settlement has been “an engineering limitation” that material science is removing. The essay is the long-form version of that claim. Luckey’s Anduril appears in the essay’s market map through its Dive-LD AUV and Australia’s Ghost Shark program.
- Seasteading — Luckey says in the clip that seasteading is “out of vogue right now but it’ll come back”; the essay ends predicting permanent ocean habitats, “seasteading, seriously.”
- Historical Futurism — a textbook past-future: the 1964 Futurama’s Hotel Atlantis, SEALAB, Cousteau’s undersea village, and kids who wanted to be aquanauts. The essay’s method is to recover a forgotten future and argue it is buildable now.
- Frontier and To Save America, Restore Our Frontier — the essay’s closing argument is the frontier thesis applied to the sea: without somewhere new to go, a civilization turns inward and stagnates.
- Maintenance — Stewart Brand’s book supplies the Golden Globe Race story the authors use to explain why the ocean is the hardest environment to keep anything working in.
- SpaceX and Starlink — the template (vertical integration, pricing for scale) and one of the four enabling curves.
- Packy McCormick and Not Boring — the co-author and publication.