Do We Need a Learning, No Greater Responsibility (Taylor Halverson)
| Author | Taylor Halverson |
|---|---|
| Published | December 12, 2017 |
| Format | Article |
| Original | Read the original |
Learning can happen without a teacher but never without a learner, so the Church’s teaching manual needs a learner’s companion, and the teacher’s real job is to be a catalyst.
Do We Need a Learning, No Greater Responsibility (Taylor Halverson)
A short op-ed (about 2,500 characters), published December 12, 2017. An editor’s note frames it as the first of three articles on teaching and learning, written as Relief Society and priesthood lesson formats were changing in 2018.
Key claims
- The Church’s best-known teaching manual is Teaching, No Greater Call; Halverson, while deferring to its “timeless truths,” asks whether a second book titled Learning, No Greater Responsibility is needed.
- The asymmetry behind the proposal is that teachers cannot exist without learners, but learners can and regularly do learn without a teacher.
- The reason to have teachers at all is catalysis. Borrowing from chemistry, a catalyst lowers the activation energy for a reaction; teaching lowers it for learning, making it happen “more quickly, effectively and efficiently.”
- Four practices move responsibility to the learner. (1) Model responsible learning, including the time, mindset, enthusiasm and joy involved. (2) Expect learners to learn, declining to answer what they can find themselves and tolerating silence while they think. (3) Give learners something to do, since “If the teacher is doing all the talking, then not much learning is happening.” (4) Encourage reflection on the effort and the joy of learning.
- Classroom silence is the obstacle; talking feels like the easiest proof that a teacher is “teaching,” which is why practice three is hard.
- When learners use their agency to own their learning, the teacher’s role becomes “not only fulfilled but also fulfilling.”
- Halverson credits his BYU colleague Richard Swan with inspiring some of the ideas.
Notable quotes
“Where there are no learners, teachers cannot exist. Yet learners can exist without teachers. All of us regularly learn without a teacher.”
“A great teacher catalyzes learning.”
“In chemistry, a catalyst is anything that lowers activation energy for a reaction to happen. If learning is the “reaction” we want to happen, teaching is the catalyst that makes learning more likely.”
“Avoid answering questions when the learners can find their own answer. Be willing to have moments of silence as leaners think, ponder and formulate how they might respond to a question.”
“Nothing seems more dreaded than the silence of a classroom.”
“But learners must do something in order to learn. Involve learners in the learning process.”
How it connects
- The learner-owns-it argument anticipates the 2019 Come, Follow Me shift to home-centered study, whose opening week in the manual is titled “We Are Responsible for Our Own Learning.”
- Taylor Halverson writes from BYU (he thanks “my BYU colleague” Richard Swan); the piece was timed to the 2018 change in Relief Society and priesthood lesson formats.