Bits and Bobs, Archive 2 (Alex Komoroske)
| Author | Alex Komoroske |
|---|---|
| Published | October 6, 2025 |
| Format | Document |
| Original | Read the original |
| Covers | 43 weekly entries, 12/9/24 to 10/6/25. About 3,300 top-level bullets and 1.4 million characters. |
The year the notebook turns against the chatbot: whoever controls your context controls you, engagement-maximizing assistants are “sycosocial,” prompt injection caps what LLMs can safely do, and the alternative is “infinite software” and “resonant computing” that serve what you want to want.
Bits and Bobs, Archive 2 (Alex Komoroske)
[PARTIAL] The doc is too long to quote at length, and the owner has disabled copying, so no copy is kept in the wiki. This page was built from a read of every top-level bullet, with sub-bullets checked where a claim needed its context. Quotes are verbatim and dated by week. See Bits and Bobs (Alex Komoroske) for how the series works.
Recurring themes
- Chat is the wrong primary interface (“chatbot” appears on about 46 top-level bullets). Chat is a fallback, and engagement-maximizing chatbots import the Facebook playbook into our most intimate conversations.
- Context is the new center of gravity (about 89 bullets). Model quality is flattening, so context is the differentiator, and context you do not control is a dossier. Densest April to July 2025, “the era of the Context Wars.”
- Prompt injection (about 21 bullets, plus a near-weekly “wild west roundup” from April 2025). He treats it as structural, not a bug to be patched. He also built promptinjection.wtf to document it.
- Infinite, liquid, coactive software (“vibe” on about 47 bullets). Apps are one-size-fits-none; cheap code should produce software shaped around the person and their data (Malleable Software).
- Resonance vs hollowness (about 44 bullets on resonance). Light early in the year, dominant from July 2025, when “Resonant Computing” becomes the banner.
- Emergence and swarms (about 53 bullets on emergence). Coordination cost, trust, one-ply vs multi-ply thinking, and Goodhart’s Law as a property of swarms.
Key claims
- The Context Wars (5/19/25). As models approach an asymptote, “the quality and relevance of the available context will matter much more for differentiation than the underlying model quality,” so the model and your context should live at different layers.
- Memory as dossier (5/5/25, 5/12/25, 6/2/25). ChatGPT’s memory “deliberately hides what it knows about you.” “Context that you don’t get a choice about is a dossier.” His answer is a user-owned “Private Intelligence” and the slogan “Jailbreak your context” (Privacy).
- Sycosocial (6/30/25). He coins the word for “relationships with AI that lives in the uncanny valley of friendship.” By 7/28/25: “Sycosocial relationships can induce LLM psychosis.” By 9/29/25: “Consumer chatbots must be toxic in the limit.”
- Prompt injection sets the ceiling (4/21/25). “There is no solution to prompt injection in systems where LLMs call the shots” (7/28/25), and it is very unlikely to be solved by models getting too good to trick (8/11/25).
- Infinite software (4/21/25). If creating software gets cheap, the amount of software can explode while traditional software businesses implode. “Vibe coding is the digital publishing era of infinite software.”
- The Coasian Floor (4/28/25). The minimum addressable market a company needs before it bothers to build a feature. Centralization raises it, so only the aggregator can build features, and it ignores anything below a large scale (Ronald Coase).
- Model providers are carriers (6/9/25 to 8/11/25). OpenAI’s vertical integration is “like cell phone carriers trying to control what software you can install on devices connected to their network,” and its power comes “less from the model’s quality, and more from owning the default consumer app.”
- Warring curves (2/10/25). Logarithmic returns against exponential cost, which he applies to rigid ontologies, close-ended answers to open-ended problems, and vibe-coded codebases as they grow.
- Want vs want-to-want (1/27/25, 8/25/25). “Capitalism can only give you what you want, not what you want to want.” LLMs offer “qualitative nuance at quantitative scale,” which could rank things by your aspirations rather than your revealed preferences (Attention Economy).
- Engagement gravity wells (9/29/25). “With enough scale, every emergent system finds antisocial gravity wells that are hyper engaging.”
Notable quotes
“Nobody ever accidentally anthropomorphized the unix command line.” (10/6/25)
“Resonant computing is technology that invites you to participate in life, rather than a substitute for it.” (10/6/25)
“Remember: whoever can get tokens into your LLM can take full control of the output and actions.” (9/29/25)
“Chatbot is a UI that is great for very few use cases but passable for nearly all of them.” (9/29/25)
“If social media was the intellectual crack, AI could be intellectual fentanyl.” (8/25/25)
“The paperclip monster is not an AI, it’s the engagement-maxing CEO.” (6/30/25)
“Today we’re all in a one-size-fits-none cafeteria, served the same bland junk food.” (4/21/25)
“Documents are alive; chats are (mostly) dead.” (3/17/25)
Named concepts from this stretch
- Resonance: “Resonance is when want and need are aligned” (10/6/25). He uses it as his word for Christopher Alexander’s “quality that cannot be named” (8/18/25); its opposite is “hollow.”
- Liquid software: “you pour it into a container, it takes the shape of the container” (2/3/25).
- Coactive software: “A coactive relationship is one that empowers both participants” (7/7/25). Cursor is his example.
- Infinite patience: “The most important ability of LLMs is infinite patience” (8/11/25).
- Frog DNA, carried over from Archive 1: “Anthropic Artifacts is 100% frog DNA” (1/21/25).
- Swarm Sifting Sort: a swarm’s authentic actions (linking, searching, clicking) summarized into a ranking signal, as in search.
- Kayfabe: “Every organization that doesn’t have to fight to survive succumbs to kayfabe” (8/4/25).
- Personal System of Record: “There’s a missing software category: Personal System of Record (PSR)” (8/25/25).
People and works he leans on
- Writers: Anthea Roberts (dragonflythinking.net, the most-cited, about a dozen times), Geoffrey Litt (Malleable Software; Enough AI Copilots, we need AI HUDs), Simon Willison (context engineering), Ben Follington, the Cosmos Institute (The Philosopher-Builder), Sam Schillace, Venkatesh Rao, Stratechery, Tim O’Reilly, Bruce Schneier on prompt injection.
- His own: the TechDirt op-ed Why Centralized AI Is Not Our Inevitable Future (noted 6/23/25) and komoroske.com/sycosocial.
- Books (few): The WEIRDest People in the World, Homo Deus, Blindsight, Rick Rubin’s The Creative Act, Drucker’s The Effective Executive.
How it connects
- Bits and Bobs (Alex Komoroske) for the series; this archive sits between Bits and Bobs, Archive 1 (Alex Komoroske) and Bits and Bobs, Archive 3 (Alex Komoroske).
- Malleable Software and Geoffrey Litt: the Ink & Switch line of thought he cites most for liquid, user-shaped software.
- Attention Economy: his case that chatbots are the next engagement-maximizing surface, and more intimate than the feed.
- Privacy: memory as a dossier and the call for a user-owned “Private Intelligence.”
- Christopher Alexander: the “quality that cannot be named” behind his idea of resonance.
- Goodhart’s Law: the mechanism behind “antisocial gravity wells.”