Bits and Bobs, Archive 1 (Alex Komoroske)
| Author | Alex Komoroske |
|---|---|
| Published | December 2, 2024 |
| Format | Document |
| Original | Read the original |
| Covers | 57 weekly entries, 10/2/23 to 12/2/24 (10/16/23 is empty). About 2,300 top-level bullets and 1.3 million characters. |
The first year of Komoroske’s weekly notebook, written mostly while he was between jobs (on 3/25/24 he is “60 hours into being ‘unemployed’”): LLMs as crystallized intuition, the coming collapse in the cost of software and what it does to apps and aggregators, and a running theory of organizations built on kayfabe, Saruman vs Radagast, and one-ply vs multi-ply thinking.
Bits and Bobs, Archive 1 (Alex Komoroske)
[PARTIAL] The doc is too long to quote at length, and the owner has disabled copying, so no copy is kept in the wiki. This page was built from a read of every top-level bullet, with sub-bullets checked where a claim needed its context. Quotes are verbatim and dated by week. See Bits and Bobs (Alex Komoroske) for how the series works.
Recurring themes
- LLMs as cultural and intuition technology (the most frequent subject: about 155 top-level bullets mention LLMs). Models intuit rather than reason, pull toward “the bland centroid,” and are only as useful as the context you give them. Prompting is closer to spell-casting than programming.
- The cost of software collapsing. The industry’s assumption that code is expensive is why we get one-size-fits-none apps and late-stage aggregators. Cheap code makes situated, personal software possible (he borrows Clay Shirky’s “situated software”).
- Organizations as emergent politics. Kayfabe (org politics as performance), Saruman vs Radagast vs Gandalf (from his essay Saruman and Radagast), and a fall-2024 thread on Founder Mode.
- Complex adaptive systems. Swarms learn even when no member does, small consistent asymmetries move the collective (the “Ouija board effect”), and Goodhart’s Law is a property of any optimized swarm (Complexity Theory).
- Ecosystems are grown, not built. Living things must stay viable at every step, Schelling points let ecosystems form (Thomas Schelling), and you should plant acorns rather than move big rocks (Adjacent Possible).
- Craft and epistemics. Knowhow can only be built by doing, taste is the moat in abundance, and leaders need disconfirming evidence that power tends to filter out.
Key claims
- The buried premise of the software industry (8/12/24). Everything in it rests on the assumption that software is expensive to write. By 9/3/24: “LLMs scramble the cost equation of software,” so “Software isn’t precious anymore.”
- A Coasian theory of the app (9/30/24). App size is set by the coordination cost of integrating with someone else’s system. Code meshes like machined gears, cheap to integrate only when you made both gears (Ronald Coase).
- Frog DNA vs shark DNA (11/25/24, 12/2/24). “Frog DNA” is the generic filler a model uses for whatever you did not specify, as in Jurassic Park. RAG and curated context substitute “shark DNA,” the specific material that keeps output from drifting to the average.
- Two conditions for the aggregator playbook (10/21/24). The would-be aggregator starts far ahead in its category (the Schelling point) and has some compounding advantage. “Aggregation always happens in every system over sufficiently long time horizons” (7/29/24) (Aggregation Theory, Ben Thompson).
- One-ply vs multi-ply (10/28/24). Sarumans see one ply of consequences. “Fast execution requires one-ply thinking,” but a swarm can do something like multi-ply thinking even when none of its members can.
- Saruman, Radagast, Gandalf. Saruman is charismatic top-down magic with uncapped reach; Radagast is gardener magic that needs deep trust and so stays local. His advice: “Be a Radagast inside your org, look like a Saruman outside of it” (8/12/24). The synthesis is Gandalf, “the systems hero” (9/9/24).
- Kayfabe has a carrying capacity (7/15/24). “Every organization grows kayfabe up to its carrying capacity,” and the capacity is set by how profitable the core business is. In layoffs the “illegibility reaper” (7/1/24) clears out whatever the org does not understand, often the load-bearing work.
- Self-capping downside (12/18/23). A dangerous startup goes out of business before it does much harm, so risky innovation is best done by “a swarm of mice, not a small number of elephants.” Same logic for writing in public: nobody will read the bad post.
- Founder mode in the state (11/4/24, 11/11/24). “Founder mode applied to the state is just plain old authoritarianism”: dictator mode breaks the feedback loop, while democracy is slow but antifragile.
- Humans in the loop (4/29/24, 7/8/24). A MidJourney-style “4-up” pattern (show four options, let a person pick, repeat) means a system can tolerate much lower input reliability and still be viable.
Notable quotes
“The entire software industry, absolutely everything in it, has a load-bearing assumption that software is expensive to write.” (8/12/24)
“LLMs are society-scale intuition crystallized into a form you can easily talk to.” (7/22/24)
“One-ply thinking can predict the emergence of cars, but not the emergence of traffic jams.” (10/28/24)
“Kayfabe looks imposing but is actually brittle, like glass.” (8/12/24)
“Silver bullets are very rare. Silver swarms are very common.” (5/20/24)
“We should move from a world of engagement-optimized computing to meaning-maximizing computing.” (10/21/24)
“Bad process is a cage. Good process is a trellis.” (1/22/24)
“If you pull an elephant out of a hat, that’s amazing… but you now have adopted an elephant.” (12/2/24)
People and works he leans on
- Writers: Gordon Brander (Subconscious, “Decentralizability”), Dimitri Glazkov, Simon Willison (“imitation intelligence”), Ben Thompson and Stratechery, Ethan Mollick (“the best available human standard”), Alison Gopnik (“stone soup AI”), Rohit Krishnan (Strange Loop Canon), Andrej Karpathy (“jagged intelligence”), Matt Webb (“No Apps, No Masters”).
- Essays: The Tyranny of the Marginal User; Clay Shirky’s Situated Software; Meta’s “Open source AI is the path forward” memo, which he called “destined to be a classic” (7/29/24).
- Books: Harari’s Nexus (“I love it”), Shirky’s Cognitive Surplus, Chris Dixon’s Read, Write, Own, Calvino’s Invisible Cities.
- Frames: Carlota Perez on technological paradigms, Herbert Simon on abundance creating scarcity, Gall’s Law.
- His own essays: Saruman and Radagast, The Doorbell in the Jungle, Gardening Platforms, Silver Swarm.
How it connects
- Bits and Bobs (Alex Komoroske): the live doc and series overview; Bits and Bobs, Archive 2 (Alex Komoroske) picks up the week after this one ends.
- Aggregation Theory: he accepts Thompson’s frame and asks what happens to it when the cost of making software falls toward zero.
- Founder Mode: his fall-2024 argument that the same pattern, applied to a state, is authoritarianism.
- Goodhart’s Law and Complexity Theory: the systems vocabulary under almost every organizational claim here.
- Adjacent Possible: his acorns-not-big-rocks advice and the “negentropic wave” of surfing what is already drifting your way.
- Ronald Coase: the seed of the Coasian theory of the app, which becomes the “Coasian Floor” in later archives.