Skip to content
kwharrison13.comEssays, books and notes by Kyle Harrison

The Straussian Moment

From kwharrison13.com · Library of Alexandria
The Straussian Moment
AuthorPeter Thiel
Published2007
FormatArticle
OriginalRead the original

TL;DR — Peter Thiel’s 2007 essay arguing that 9/11 exposed the limits of Enlightenment politics, read through Locke, Carl Schmitt, Leo Strauss and René Girard.

Peter Thiel, identified in the byline as president of Clarium Capital Management, opens with Tennyson’s “Locksley Hall” and with September 11, which he argues called the whole modern framework of deterrence, rational nation-states and diplomacy into question. His central exhibit is bin Laden: a rich, educated Saudi, not a poor man, which in his reading shows that economic incentives cannot contain violence and that the economically minded political thought of the modern West, from Smith to Marx, is incomplete.

The essay then works through four thinkers. Under “John Locke: The American Compromise” it treats liberalism as a deliberate agreement not to ask hard questions about human nature. “Carl Schmitt: The Persistence of the Political” takes up the friend-enemy distinction, and rejects Schmitt’s answer as too violent for a nuclear age. “Leo Strauss: Proceed with Caution” covers esoteric writing and makes a case for action outside open debate, naming Echelon, the secret coordination of intelligence services, rather than the United Nations as the path to a global pax Americana. “René Girard: The End of the City of Man” sets out mimetic desire and the founding murder, and argues that the Judeo-Christian revelation is steadily unveiling them.

A closing section, “History and Knowledge,” frames the dispute between Strauss and Girard as a question of time: whether that knowledge can stay with a philosophical elite or will become common. It ends by asking what a Christian statesman should do, and answers in negatives: no return to Schmitt’s archaic politics, no accommodation with the Enlightenment, and no retreat into waiting for the Second Coming. The PDF is pages 189–218 of the edited collection Politics and Apocalypse (2007), with about a hundred endnotes.

What it is: A signed essay in an academic volume, not peer-reviewed scholarship. It is a primary source on Thiel’s political and religious thought.

Where this came from

30 pages. A copy is archived locally against link rot; the header links the original source.

Curated by Kyle Harrison. Organized by Claude. Written by the near-sentient amalgamation of spirit, intellect, and artificial intelligence.