Skip to content
kwharrison13.comEssays, books and notes by Kyle Harrison

Something Is Happening to America's Moral Code

From kwharrison13.com · Long read
Something Is Happening to America's Moral Code
AuthorGraeme Wood
PublishedApril 24, 2026
FormatArticle
OriginalRead the original

When a New York Times podcast had Hasan Piker and Jia Tolentino cheerfully endorse shoplifting and theft as resistance to tyranny, it revealed comfortable people playing outlaw, ignorant of the left’s own history and too cowardly to accept the penalty real civil disobedience requires.

Something Is Happening to America’s Moral Code

Key claims

  • The setup. On April 22, 2026, a The New York Times podcast hosted by Nadja Spiegelman had Twitch streamer Hasan Piker and New Yorker staff writer Jia Tolentino discuss lawbreaking, which both endorsed as resistance to “actual tyranny, today.”
  • What they endorsed. Shoplifting from grocery chains like Whole Foods (Tolentino claimed, without evidence, that “every major grocery chain” steals from workers and customers); ripping off streaming services such as Spotify, which carries the Times podcast; Piker said he would steal cars “if I could get away with it”; Tolentino encouraged stealing from her own employer.
  • Violence, giggled around. Both said “no” to murdering health-insurance executives (Piker citing legal advice) while calling insurers guilty of “social murder” and sympathetically explaining why Americans might respond with actual murder.
  • The Times double standard. Six years earlier the paper’s opinion editor lost his job over a Tom Cotton op-ed on invoking the Insurrection Act; now the Times recommends listening to this podcast “for the full effect.”
  • Unoppressed outlaws. Wood mocks the Scandinavian-minimalist set and Ralph Lauren outfits; Spiegelman invokes Jean Valjean but her example is “organic avocados,” and Piker wants to “get back to cool crimes” like Louvre heists.
  • Historical illiteracy. Roughly 200 years of leftist thought went into arranging governments so labor can bargain fairly; the podcast acts as if the upshot is that “you can simply take things.” Piker’s favorable comparisons to China and Cuba ignore that the Chinese model punishes individual defiance and treats the individual as worth nothing.
  • The cowardice point. Theft is fine to them as long as no one has to look anyone in the eye; “micro-looting” is a euphemism to avoid the word shoplifting. Wood pairs this with the James C. Scott frame of “anarchist calisthenics”: small acts of disobedience to keep civic muscles strong.
  • King’s standard. Civil disobedience, per Martin Luther King Jr., should be done “openly, lovingly, and with a willingness to accept the penalty”; breaking the law proudly is what earns merit, not evading responsibility for shoplifting produce.

Notable quotes

“Crime, to these people, appears to be a series of Thomas Crown affairs, punctuated for some reason by free guacamole.”

“They could not look or sound more unoppressed if they tried.”

“(The belief that you are oppressed by Whole Foods, however, is a modern psychosis.)”

“One can agree or disagree that this model is the right one, but one cannot love the Chinese system and love rampant criminality, even ‘cool crimes.’”

“Fretting over trivia such as using a plastic cup, then treating weighty matters such as murder with the same gravity, may be a source of the moral vertigo.”

“You have to break the law proudly—not break it, then run away to another state and get caught with a fake ID in a McDonald’s.”

“Leftists need calisthenics too. These people are all flab.”

How it connects

Curated by Kyle Harrison. Organized by Claude. Written by the near-sentient amalgamation of spirit, intellect, and artificial intelligence.