Politigram & the Post-left
| Author | Joshua Citarella |
|---|---|
| Published | 2018 |
| Format | Report |
| Original | Read the original |
TL;DR — Artist Joshua Citarella’s 2018 field report on “Politigram,” teen political meme communities on Instagram, tracing a group of young leftists toward anti-tech primitivism, egoism and nihilism.
This is the abridged “short version” of a book Citarella first self-published in late September 2018 as a small-edition artist’s book (about 55 copies, sold by direct message and email). It was meant as a handbook for the art world on online political spaces; a copy bought in New York was scanned and posted online within weeks, and this release followed. The text notes it is heavily redacted to protect small accounts.
Citarella describes Politigram — “political radicals on Instagram” — as mostly white teenage boys aged 12 to 17, with every ideology represented and an unusual habit of following and debating their opponents. He sketches the 2015–16 drift of anarcho-capitalist teens toward the alt-right, then turns to his main subject: a small group of teens who began as anarcho-communists and syndicalists, backed Bernie Sanders, lost faith in electoral politics after the 2016 primary and election, and moved toward “post-left” positions. He walks through the stages he observed: anarcho-primitivism and anti-civilization ideas (John Zerzan, James C. Scott), the egoism of Max Stirner, accelerationism and the work of Nick Land, admiration for Ted Kaczynski, and finally a “Cybernihilism” that blends tech pessimism, primitivist anxiety and transhumanist detachment.
The argument running through it is that the mainstream left’s failure to offer a compelling vision of the future is losing young people to nihilism, and that social media isolates users and speeds up radicalization. The pages mix essay text with reproduced memes, political-compass charts and screenshots; the full version was to add chat logs, interviews and census data from the users themselves.
What it is: Participant-observation by an artist and self-described amateur anthropologist, not academic research. No systematic sampling or data; a vivid, early first-hand account of a youth internet subculture that later drew wider attention.
Where this came from
- Will Manidis’s “most underrated PDF” thread, July 2023 — routing record: The Most Underrated PDF on the Internet (July 2023)
40 pages. A copy is archived locally against link rot; the header links the original source.