Skip to content
kwharrison13.comEssays, books and notes by Kyle Harrison

Non-Cap Weighted Indexes

From kwharrison13.com · Library of Alexandria
Non-Cap Weighted Indexes
AuthorClifford S. Asness
Published2007
FormatReport
OriginalRead the original

TL;DR — Cliff Asness’s slides from the Q-Group’s spring 2007 seminar, arguing that fundamental indexing is only a value tilt away from cap-weighting, new in nothing but marketing.

Presented in March 2007 at The Cloister, Sea Island, Georgia, the deck by AQR’s founding principal takes aim at Rob Arnott’s Fundamental Indexing (FI). It opens with a cartoon dialogue in which “Rob” announces his discovery of “fundamental attraction” and Asness keeps answering that it is called gravity.

The core is a “one liner”: a stock’s weight in a fundamental index equals its cap weight multiplied by its book-to-price ratio relative to the market’s, so FI is “precisely, and exactly, and only a value tilt.” Asness accepts that FI has higher expected returns than cap-weighting and that noise in prices helps explain why, but disputes every claim of originality, citing Fischer Black’s 1986 “Noise” address and later behavioural-finance work. He also objects to calling an active strategy an “index”, to the claimed trillion-dollar capacity, and to Arnott’s comparisons with the Russell Value index.

The conclusion describes FI as a roughly 5% tracking-error, four-factor quantitative value tilt — “active quant management circa 1992 sans momentum” — backed by a regression on Kenneth French’s data from 1968 to 2007.

What it is: A practitioner’s conference talk: polemical, funny, and from a manager competing in the same market, but its central argument is simple algebra anyone can check.

Where this came from

50 pages. A copy is archived locally against link rot; the header links the original source.

Curated by Kyle Harrison. Organized by Claude. Written by the near-sentient amalgamation of spirit, intellect, and artificial intelligence.