Jerry Seinfeld Says Movies Are Over — Here's Why He Made One Anyway (GQ)
| Author | Brett Martin |
|---|---|
| Published | April 22, 2024 |
| Format | Interview |
| Original | Read the original |
On the eve of his directorial debut Unfrosted, Jerry Seinfeld says film has lost its cultural pinnacle and show business is disoriented, while stand-up holds up because it is a craft audiences can verify, and his whole philosophy reduces to “Get good at something.”
Jerry Seinfeld Says Movies Are Over — Here’s Why He Made One Anyway (GQ)
The piece is a short profile followed by a long Q&A; the quotes below are Seinfeld’s answers unless marked otherwise.
Key claims
- The movie business is over. Making Unfrosted (a Pop-Tart origin story set in 1960s Battle Creek, Michigan, with Jim Gaffigan and Amy Schumer as the Kellogg’s and Post bosses, from an idea by Seinfeld writer Spike Feresten) was “totally new” to him at nearly 70. The crew were “so dead serious,” but “film doesn’t occupy the pinnacle in the social, cultural hierarchy that it did for most of our lives.”
- Disorientation, not depression. “Disorientation replaced the movie business. Everyone I know in show business, every day, is going, What’s going on?”
- Craft as insulation. Stand-up is “like you’re a cabinetmaker, and everybody needs a guy who’s good with wood”; good craftsmanship makes you “kind of impervious to the whims of the industry.” Audiences flock to stand-up “because it’s something you can’t fake,” like platform diving.
- Directing vs. stand-up. Directing “feels like running a ranch in the West… broken fences and filth”; a good set feels like surfing, catching “this gigantic energy and… just sliding down it.” “There’s nothing pure in making a movie. There’s no flow.”
- One thing, not many. “I don’t believe in being good at a lot of things—or even more than one.” He tried surfing for a week twenty years ago and stopped; if he got to be human again he would just surf: “You want to be broke. You want it to be all you’ve got.”
- Who made Seinfeld work. The “Seinfeld paradox” (so New York and Jewish, yet syndicated everywhere) is solved, he says, by Jason Alexander, Julia Louis-Dreyfus and Michael Richards, who “made this unrelatable material accessible.” He now likes the much-criticized jail-cell finale and the characters: “You can’t do comedy without selfish people.”
- Real laughs over confession. He wants “something that couldn’t possibly have happened,” not “amusing anecdotes from your journal.” His warning to young comics: “your only flotation device in the oceanic waters of show business is real laughs,” because “I know a million comedians whose work dried up at 53.”
- Curb’s callback and the Israel trip. He calls appearing in the Curb Your Enthusiasm finale, a joke “set up 25 years ago and then paid off 25 years later,” a career highlight. On visiting Israel after October 7, he says antisemitism had been “from history books” for Jews of his generation; he keeps his strong feelings private and out of the act.
- Happiness in the work. Explaining why he would not trade his career for ten years on the Mets, he points to Mets broadcasters Gary Cohen, Keith Hernandez and Ron Darling as rare people “happy doing what they’re doing,” and recalls walking into a comedy club at about 18: “Oh, I’m home.”
Notable quotes
“Every world is lost. It’s all lost. Whatever you remember, it’s gone. Forget it. One of people’s great foolishnesses is thinking, This is the way it is.” — Seinfeld
“Stand-up is like you’re a cabinetmaker, and everybody needs a guy who’s good with wood.”
“Audiences are now flocking to stand-up because it’s something you can’t fake. It’s like platform diving.”
“I don’t believe in being good at a lot of things—or even more than one.”
“People are always trying to add more stuff to life. Reduce it to simpler, pure moments. That’s the golden way of living, I think.”
“I just think if you are a comedian and you want to survive, your only flotation device in the oceanic waters of show business is real laughs.”
“There’s nothing I revile quite as much as a dilettante. I don’t like doing something to a mediocre level. It’s great to be 70, because you really get to preach with some authority: Get good at something. That’s it. Everything else is bullshit.”
How it connects
- Jerry Seinfeld · Seinfeld’s Calendar — the daily-practice habit the wiki already credits to him fits his “get good at something” ethic here.
- Mastery · Craft — the cabinetmaker metaphor and the contempt for dilettantes.
- Write Like a Comedian — Capital Camp (David Perell) — the comedian-as-model-writer argument, from the craft side.