How a Theology Professor Joined The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Maxwell Institute)
| Author | Maxwell Institute (Rosalynde Welch with John B. White) |
|---|---|
| Published | September 30, 2026 |
| Format | Podcast |
| Original | Read the original |
| Length | 46 minutes. Published September 30, 2026. |
A Baylor theological ethicist who spent his career on the theology of the body describes how reading the Book of Mormon, a visit to the Sacred Grove and a sense of “belonging before believing” brought him into the Church, and why its doctrine of an embodied God made his earlier work on embodiment and sacramentality “glow with a new light.”
How a Theology Professor Joined The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Transcript note: the transcript below comes from YouTube’s automatic captions, lightly cleaned (filler tags removed, paragraphs joined). Speaker turns start a new paragraph but are not labelled; Welch asks the questions. Names are as the captions heard them, so “Roslyn”/“Russell” for Rosalynde and “Dr. Janay Nelson” are uncertain.
Key claims
- Who he is. Per the episode description, White spent 14 years at Baylor University as a professor of practical theology and ethics, directed its Graduate Chaplaincy Program, co-founded the Faith & Sports Institute with his wife Cindy, and holds a PhD in theological ethics from the University of Edinburgh. He joined the Maxwell Institute as a visiting research fellow in January 2026, and he says he knew joining the Church meant he “would lose my job at Baylor.”
- The gym as a deadening place. Welch opens with White’s essay Fitness Centers and Health Clubs: Missing the Mark. His complaint: machines that measure and monitor turn exercise into quantification, the body becomes “a project or a tool,” and gym culture reinforces performance, visual presentation and mastery. Welch’s gloss is that the gym gives “too much and too little attention to the body.”
- Sacrament on a continuum. In his paper Sacramentally Imagining Sports, “sacramental” means the outward and physical participating in an invisible reality. Formal liturgies (sacrament meeting, the temple) are the intensive end; sport, played as mutual striving and as a gift of the body to others, can sit at the extensive end. He cites Alma 31 to 34 (worship not bound to a place) against the sacred/secular dichotomy, which he calls “another form of dualism.”
- The conversion path. About two and a half years before the interview, a period of anxiety, sleeplessness and professional displacement (he links it to the Book of Mormon’s “compelled humility”) was followed by seeing a physical light above a BYU professor at a conference, who became a collaborator and a gentle evangelist. He insists he was “not a spiritual project,” and says an instrumentalizing pitch would have repeated the gym’s mistake.
- The Book of Mormon as a sensory book. Reading it, he was struck by the language of “swelling, enlightening, enlarging, and tasting,” which began “to convict” him. He read the whole book before baptism.
- The Sacred Grove moment. On a road trip he heard Moroni 10:4 to 5 in a sacrament meeting, read it at the Hill Cumorah and again at the Grandin Press, where a senior missionary told him to read it and “insert your name.” He calls that the point where “I met God,” and frames conversion as ongoing (“We have been saved. We are being saved. We will be saved.”).
- Belonging before believing. He felt “a very embodied belonging” with Latter-day Saints before full belief, and the culture of speaking about feelings went from sounding “cliché and trite” to meaningful once he was “inside the grammar of the restored gospel.” Welch adds the passing of sacrament trays down the pew as a physical enactment of that belonging.
- An embodied Father changes the theology of the body. In his Episcopal and evangelical background the sacramental imagination “always pointed to something that was bodiless.” The Latter-day Saint doctrine that the Father has a body of flesh and bones (he cites Doctrine and Covenants and Tertullian’s “the flesh is the hinge of salvation”) makes the body “less of a window and more of a conduit.”
- The Word of Wisdom as a metaphysic of the body. His father was an alcoholic, and he gave up drinking 8 to 10 months before adopting the Word of Wisdom. He now argues it “shows that this dwelling is substantively good.” Welch’s point: observance begins as restriction and matures when it is held “intrinsically” and “integrally.”
- Proxy ordinances as the body’s gift. Welch calls temple proxy work the most “body positive aspect of Latter-day Saint theology.” White, drawing on the intrinsic goods of sport, says “the logic of gift continues even after death”; Welch extends it to being “small S saviors on Mount Zion.”
Notable quotes
“I’m suspicious that something might be wrong with how this place envisions and shapes bodies, with the way in which health clubs picture our bodies and roll them in repetitive practices that upon reflection might trespass against our God-given graced bodies.” White, reading his own essay (3:47)
“And ironically, there’s sort of too much and too little attention to the body in that environment.” Welch (6:45)
“And so every physical medium, every material reality is capable of carrying, embodying, and communicating divine presence.” White (12:27)
“I remember saying I’m not a spiritual project and she made it very clear I don’t I want your best you know the best version of yourself.” White (19:02)
“I feel like I belonged before I believed and it was a very embodied belonging, a very physical connection.” White (25:40)
“suddenly all the work you had done previously on embodiment, on sacramentality, on incarnation, suddenly this kind of glows with a new light and new significance from the inside.” Welch (about 33:30; also the episode’s cold open)
“my wife’s grandmother once said that anything that’s truly worthy or worth something, it’ll cost you something.” White (37:07)
“And so I guess um kind of the the logic of gift continues even after death.” White (43:25)
How it connects
- The Book of Mormon: the sensory vocabulary of the text and the Moroni 10:4 to 5 promise (Moroni) are the hinges of White’s conversion.
- Sacred Grove: the pilgrimage where the conference “light” finally made sense to him, via the light in Joseph Smith’s First Vision.
- Word of Wisdom: recast as a positive practice that treats the body as a temple rather than a list of prohibitions.
- Baptism: Welch’s reading of baptism by immersion as the most viscerally embodied ordinance, and proxy baptism as its extension.
- Restoration: White’s framing of his past traditions as preparatory, fulfilled rather than rejected.
- Neal A. Maxwell: the namesake of the institute that hosts the podcast and now employs White.
- The Embodied Mind: a parallel account, from cognitive science rather than theology, of the mind as inseparable from the body that White argues against mind-body dualism from.
- Attention Economy: White’s critique of the device-mediated gym, measuring calories rather than listening to the body, is a small case of the same quantification problem.
Transcript
[0:00] I started to meet with the missionaries. The first meeting I said I I’ve been converted and be baptized. I said I got to catch here. I want to be baptized in Utah.
Suddenly all the work you had done previously on embodiment, on sacramentality, suddenly this kind of glows with a new light and new significance from the inside.
I didn’t realize how rich this is as far as the materiality in the restored gospel.
Hello. I’m Rosalynde Welch, associate director of Brigham Young University’s Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship. Today I have for you an interview with my colleague John White, who joined us at the Maxwell Institute in January of 2026. John brings the disciplines of ethics and theology to practical questions about sports and embodiment. In addition to publishing top-notch academic work, John has published work for broad audiences in Sports Illustrated and USA Today, and has worked directly with athletes through the Faith and Sports Institute, which he founded with his wife Cindy, and through the BYU Y Sport program for young athletes.
But it’s not only for his research that I invited him on the podcast. John has been on a spiritual quest that recently brought him into the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Like all conversion stories, John’s is complex, inspiring, and full of sacrifice as well as blessings. Please enjoy my interview with Dr. John White. John White, welcome to the Maxwell Institute podcast.
It’s good to be here, Rosalynde.
John, you’ve been my colleague here at the Maxwell Institute since January of 2026. You came here to join us as part of a personal and spiritual journey that brought you into communion with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. So you’re now a member of the church. I’m delighted to have you as a colleague and as a brother in Christ.
We’re going to talk about your conversion today, but I want to approach it a little different angle. Hopefully a way maybe you haven’t thought about it before, and maybe a way of thinking about conversion that will be new to our listeners as well. I want to think about a spiritual conversion by way of the body. How does the body experience a conversion to Christ? I think this is an interesting question in its own right, but it’s especially fitting for you because your professional life and work, you are an ethicist and a practical theologian, has focused on the body, on various forms of embodiment, and especially on the body in sports. And what are the theological and spiritual implications of that moment? So we’re going to use that as a lens to eventually get towards your conversion. But let’s start at a very different place. You wrote um a really wonderful essay called Fitness Centers and Health Clubs, Missing the Mark. And I love your introduction to this essay.
You describe a moment where you find yourself in a gym working out, and you have this realization. John, would you read for us the opening paragraphs of this great essay?
Sure will. Over the last 20 years, I have frequently found myself in fitness clubs where after work I run on treadmills, clip my feet into life cycles pedals, and trudge up the escalating steps of a stair master, only to experience my doppelganger whisper, this is a mistake or worse, this is deadening. My professional life already does heavy mental lifting, though in the sedentary context of computer generated realities with little consciousness of my lived body experience. Indeed, I move from laptops and other office and education related technologies, which rule my vocation as professor, to a room full of more machines which disciplines my exercise.
[3:47] I’m suspicious that something might be wrong with how this place envisions and shapes bodies, with the way in which health clubs picture our bodies and roll them in repetitive practices that upon reflection might trespass against our God-given graced bodies. And yet I keep finding ways to ignore what might be wrong about how this pacemaker contribute to my malformation because I outwardly receive enough of a reward to detach ironically from whatever troubles me upon deeper reflection. After a sweat producing and pound reducing workout, I enjoy knowing that I can indulge a scoop of even two of Ben & Jerry’s or eat extra chips and salsa while waiting for my main entree.
I can relate to that in so many ways. I’m sure our listeners can as well. From the sort of desk job during the day, right, where we sit sort of disconnected from our bodies to then maybe our exercise session where we’re at a gym and again, we’re sort of maybe in our head even as we’re exercising our bodies and we just feel that something isn’t right. I want you to take me a little deeper into that moment. You had this intuition that something was deadening about that environment. Talk to me a little bit about what went wrong there. Why was the gym environment in particular deadening to your relationship with your body?
I think for me, even at first when I started going back in the gym on a regular basis, I was finishing my dissertation. So I would take books in there and I’d be reading these books which, you know, I was trying to multitask as much done as I could. And I found myself just kind of disassociating that what I was doing was very disembodied. It was not connected to actually feeling, sensing all the five senses of my body. And I just found this like alienation. I I felt like there was a view of a body that’s going that’s at work here uh that seems to be not congruent or in agreement with the Christian tradition. I found myself more operating from the mind and even using the machines as a way of measuring and monitoring and assessing and gauging whether I was keeping up my level of fitness and still divorcing me from any kind of intimate relationship with my body.
I’m sure many of us have done this, right? You’re exercising on the machine, you’re watching the calories burnt go up and up and then you’re sort of mentally calculating, well, that means I can have this much more ice cream after dinner tonight. And exercise kind of becomes um an exercise in quantification, in measurement. And my body seems to me sort of like a project or a tool, right? That I’m trying to manipulate, not for its own purposes, but for my purposes, whether that be that I want to look good to somebody else or that I want to present in the world in a certain way or even that I want to meet some sort of performance metric. Gym culture kind of reinforces the this ethos of performance, of visual presentation, and of mastering and disciplining the body.
And ironically, there’s sort of too much and too little attention to the body in that environment. You’re intensely focused on it and on others, comparing your body to others, but at the same time, you aren’t really focused on what your body itself wants to do, is meant to do, what its purpose is. I wonder if you talk about that a little bit. What would it look like to inhabit our body from the inside and to let our body’s own goals and own projects be expressed in our physical activity?
Yeah, that’s a great question. So I think the body has its own language. I mean, it’s not language of like a spoken word so much, but it has a language that requires us to get comfortable in listening to it. So I think that what that means in in a health club is that when I go in there, maybe I shouldn’t be going in there with all these other ways of connecting to devices, to technology. I primarily use health clubs now when maybe weather is inclement weather or, you know, at some time in the day I can’t I can’t go outside, but I prefer to actually go outside. And I’ve often thought about the sports that I excelled in most were swimming, which can be done outside, but we did have pools and obviously on the inside in the Midwest.
[7:56] Uh but then cycling and then golf. And I I’m not sure that at a young age that I thought about this because it brought me more in contact with nature and my body, but now upon deeper reflection, I I really receive more of a kind of a gift relationship with my body. So listening to my body, trying to feel my body, that’s where I think devices can help you, right? To monitor that. If you recognize that your heart rate maybe is saying something about you’re overworking or something like that, but trying to actually just gauge that myself, that I can take my pulse myself, that I can I can hear my breathing. There’s a guy in the health club that I was at at the fitness center today on campus, and I hear him breathing, and sometimes it’s irritating to me, but today I was thinking in anticipation of this like that’s actually good. Like he’s he’s alive, you know? I think probably trying to listen to those different aspects of our body and what they’re communicating to us.
I love Mumford & Sons, and I actually went to school with Marcus Mumford, the lead vocalist, his brother, James Mumford. He was doing a PhD at Oxford, and we were we had the same professor we were studying under who was at Edinburgh at that time. Marcus Mumford has a song called Awake My Soul, and I love this it says in these bodies we live, in these bodies we die. Where we invest our love, that’s where we invest our life. I think phenomenologically that’s a rich song, and that so how can I actually understand how am I loving my body in a way that’s consistent with how God created my body?
We may have inherited some unhelpful ways of thinking about our body from kind of western thought in general, right? Especially the notorious mind-body dualism. And that’s where I kind of have a sense that I am something outside and apart from my body, and that what really matters is what I want, and I use my body to achieve those goals rather than instead understanding my soul as an integration, a fully integrated unity of flesh and and spirit. When we see ourselves in that latter way, I think we understand ourselves in relation to all creation, right? First of all, we understand ourselves as creations of God. Maybe that’s partly why it’s so much more rewarding when possible to exercise in the out of doors, because we are in the midst of God’s created world, and we can more easily maybe experience ourselves in continuity with that world and experience ourselves as God’s good creation. And this moves us, I think, towards a more Christian based um understanding of how the body can and should operate in the world, even in exercise. And as you say, sometimes we may we may need to take our heart rate, right? We we go to doctors, we do relate to our body in ways that require metrics and quantification.
That’s not inherently bad. Um but I think as we do that, there are ways that we can um foreground our creatureliness. There’s this really wonderful um sentence in this essay that I want to read because it’s a great transition. Rather than cherishing the body as a gift in which exercise can reawaken and remake contact with the integrity of our bodies and with the world we inhabit, the experience of the health club tempts us to forget that it is in these bodies that we feel and move in the world. And this moves us toward what you call a sacramental imagination of sports. You have another paper called Sacramentally Imagining Sports. Um this might at first kind of strike our listeners a little strangely, right? We tend to use the word sacrament narrowly in the Latter-day Saint tradition to refer to the Lord’s Supper that we celebrate together on Sundays. But there’s a broader meaning of sacrament and sacramental that that encompasses sort of all of the created world. So talk for a minute about how you are using this idea of sacrament and sacramental in relation to sport.
[11:54] That’s good. That’s a great distinction. So I see a sacramental [snorts] understanding really on a continuum. The difference is by degree. And so we have these intensive liturgies like sacrament meeting. But then throughout the week, what’s happening is that um a lot of writers talk about this more of an extensive uh kind of liturgy where we think about a sacramental understanding is where the the outward, the physical, the visible participates in this invisible reality. And so every physical medium, every material reality is capable of carrying, embodying, and communicating divine presence. And that’s could be shocking to people. And I think it’s been shocking because we have this kind of sacred-secular dichotomy. Again, another form of dualism. And I would want to argue that every area of life is pervaded with the with the with the spiritual, with the with the sacred.
By bringing those together, there’s not a gap in my experience of what I’m doing outside of the church, right? It’s it’s important and significant never to replace uh the liturgies of church, never to replace attending and participating in in the temple. We also want to recognize that wherever we go, these are places that with worship is not time-bound or or location-bound. And I even see this in Alma 32 when Alma and Amulek are addressing the Zoramites, right? From 31 to 34. Uh they’re kind of confused. They’ve been displaced. The very places that they built these synagogues, uh they’re Alma and Amulek argue that there’s a you can worship God wherever. Uh so the sacramental imagination actually blends into that very nicely. Our body is meant to be a self-donation, meant to be given to other people. And so sports is a medium where we can do that. Sports is actually a contested area where a controlled environment where we can learn to communicate our bodies. If we have a proper view of excellence, that it’s this mutual striving together.
And so a sacramental understanding for sports uh instead of it being just simply uh the body as a tool or as an implement as you indicated, uh that it starts with this idea of gift. Um and that I’m supposed to give to you and then you receive that gift of body from me. Again, there are sports that you can just do individually, but most sports are are collaborative, they’re cooperative, right? They’re against and with other people.
So in this broad sense of the sacramental, any physical object or gesture can channel God’s grace and make it present and manifest to it, to us. That can happen formally in in the ordinances of the gospel, but it can also happen informally in everyday life, maybe especially at those moments in everyday life where we are behaving most like God does, right? Where we are most exercising our godly capacities of self-giving and of excellence and of creativity. Um and in those moments we can have kind of experiences deeply grounded in our body um that can give us an intuition of God’s presence and God’s power, and we can think of those as sacraments of of a kind. So with that journey in mind from a a moment of feeling deadened in your body to a moment of feeling sacramentally alive in your body, let’s now take that journey and walk it through your conversion. Tell us where you started, how did you first become acquainted with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and as I’m going to be prompting you throughout, how was that in your body? How did you experience that in an embodied way?
Good. Thank you. Uh so one qualifier as I explain this, I always like to tell folks that when I talk about my conversion in the restored gospel, it’s never uh denigration or rejection of my past. I believe God was at work there and I really see kind of a kind of a history of unfolding so that the work that he was doing was preparatory to the fulfillment and the completion of the work that preceded that. Does that make sense? Just in principle. I think because as listeners, I don’t want people to think that somehow what happened before God wasn’t at work there. It’s like, no, he was at work there.
And let me just let me just interject here to say that is so clear that who you are as a human being um has been so fruitfully, carefully, and lovingly nurtured not only by God through your past, but by the communities and the relationships that that brought you to where you are now. So we give thanks to to all the people and institutions in your past um that brought you to where you are now, and we recognize them as our as our friends in Christ.
Well, thank you. Uh it was probably about two and a half years ago um that I was um uh there was a restlessness in my life um and I’d had other kind of episodes of this, but I really started to listen to this and it was it was physical too. In fact, I was I was I was there was anxiety, there was sleeplessness, uh and there was some just some trauma in my life that I was working through, and even professionally there was some displacement that was occurring. This again in the Book of Mormon uh which we read in in Alma about this compelled humility. And so God was at work in my life to kind of rearrange kind of the moral mental furniture in my life where maybe I was dependent too much upon myself.
Uh we we’ve referred to that as a vice of pride. And so there were some things that I was really wrestling with. I was presenting at a conference and uh it was at this conference uh that when I was presenting I saw this light uh that was over this person that um I didn’t know what to do with this. In fact, I didn’t talk about this publicly at all because I didn’t have the restored gospel or a hermeneutic to make sense of something like this. Uh I was I’m a theologian, so we work in reason and syllogisms, uh empirical evidence. Uh all that to say it was significant enough that when this scholar came up to me, uh who’s a professor here at BYU, Dr. Nelson, I was attentive because she was there because I she was mentoring a former student of mine. She wasn’t there to hear me, but I happened to be one of the presenters in this symposium. This began then a conversation because she was interested in some of the research I was doing.
[18:04] And that that light had me begin to think maybe I need to listen to what this person is saying because that was disturbing to me. I mean I didn’t know what to make sense of that.
Would you have said it was sort of a physical light that you saw with your physical eyes?
was a physical light. In fact, I asked Dr. Janay Nelson, I asked her and she goes there was height above me. And I said, yes, there was. Uh and so um I didn’t I didn’t again, I didn’t make sense of this until about a year later when I made this pilgrimage uh to um the Sacred Grove and I learned about that the light was restored in the revelation to Joseph Smith. And so that light that occurred there uh is more of kind of um more of an awakening just to be open because here I am going to this humbling experience and maybe I needed to start to divert my attention to something else. And so that conversation began with us collaborating and peppered with gospel conversations. I mean, I was being evangelized. Uh but but but with all sensitivity, I remember saying I’m not a spiritual project and she made it very clear I don’t I want your best you know the best version of yourself.
What would have happened if you had sensed that she kind of really had this strong goal to to convert you? How how would you have responded to that?
Well, it would have been consistent with the very problem I had with um fitness centers. That would have felt instrumentalized. Uh that the body that I’m being misused, right? Instead of just enjoying the collaboration, the friendship, uh I think I would have been I think I would have been turned off. Uh but I do I do recognize that it was unconventional. It was another scholar and that I needed someone that would be be willing to challenge me and and follow up questions that I had. It opened up a whole new um uh kind of reservoir of of of collaborators and just people that would be willing to talk to me about some of the investigation that I had at that time.
So having said all that, uh I got my first Book of Mormon shortly after that and uh I began to read it and I recognized there’s something fundamentally different about this book. I realized that this is a very sensual in the sense of five senses uh book and I remember reading about swelling, enlightening, enlarging, and tasting. I was like, wow, this is this is wild. This is in the this is in the book. This is in the book scripture. That was beginning to convict me that there’s something truthful about this, and I started to feel but you as you point out here, we all experience takes the body as its ground. It’s simply must, right? So a spiritual experience is necessarily a bodily experience, whether that be through visual experiences like seeing a light or through sensory experiences, feeling something within your body, or through interpreting and and becoming alive to the sensory imagery in scripture. It’s interesting that religious practice itself takes the body as its ground in very simple ways, right? If you’re a Latter-day Saint, then on Sunday mornings you go and you sit still for an hour in sacrament meeting, unless um you’re wrestling children in which it’s you’re not sitting still at all. And then you stand up and walk for 5 minutes, and then you’re sitting again. So our body behaves in very certain ways during ritual in the temple, of course. We um follow a very beautifully prescribed sort of choreographies of ordinances there. Um what we take into our body through the word of wisdom, right? Um our our spiritual beliefs um inhabit our bodies and are instantiated in our bodies in a myriad of ways. So I’m wondering how that played out for you. Um sometimes when it comes to conversion, we want to know the beginning and the end. We want to know how you how you first met the church, and then we want to skip to the happy ending. But for most people, there’s some of the richest part comes right there in the middle as your in this process of turning from an old life and an old way of life, um not abandoning it, but fulfilling it, enriching it, deepening it towards a new form of life. Tell us a little bit about the middle part of your conversion before baptism, and again how that played out in in your bodily practices and in your body itself.
Well, I’ll go back to the Sacred Grove experience. So, I had a conference out there and I was decided to take a road trip. And this is when I just started reading the Book of Mormon, so I had fresh eyes. And I didn’t realize it this time, but the missionary promise in Moroni 10 4 and 5. And so I I was familiar with it. I’d read it. I hadn’t read through the whole Book of Mormon. I ended up reading through the whole Book of Mormon before I got baptized. That was just a commitment I feel like I needed to do. So I was starting to make this a part of my spiritual diet and when I went there, we went to the sacrament meeting that morning and we heard Moroni 10 4 and 5 again. And And it was through tears. This gentleman was sharing and it affected me.
And And then that afternoon we decided to make kind of the trek through the the Sacred Grove. We went to Hill Cumorah first and we read Moroni 10 4 and 5. Then we got to the top, Moroni 10 4 and 5. And then we did the whole Sacred Grove experience. We went to Is it Grandin Press? Yeah, we went there. And that’s where a senior missionary, which I didn’t even know there were senior missionaries at that point. I thought there was just, you know, the young missionaries.
I was like, wait, what? You do this at You You do this when you’re 18. You do this again when you’re 70 or 60. And so but this this woman was so gentle, so kind. And she said, why don’t you read Moroni 10 4 and 5 it was encased. And she said, insert your name.
And so at up to this point I would say most of my experience with God was very cognitive as a theologian. And this was kind of this There was a work happening as far as what we refer to as a spiritual epistemology, working on my spiritual senses, but in in very embodied. And as I she said, insert your name in place of ye. And I did that and I just It was at that point that I feel like I had a divine encounter. Again, I I see conversion is ongoing. We have been saved. We are being saved. We will be saved. It’s kind of the New Testament understanding of that. But But I would say as far as restored gospel, that’s when I met God. Uh and it was and then I remember texting people saying I believe after that. Um so there was something had registered in me in that experience. But I would also say one of the things I recognized early on in the Latter-day Saint community was this idea of talking about your emotions and feeling. In fact just yesterday I met with my bishop and during that time he said to me again I knew I was preparing for this so maybe I just kind of amplified something that he said but he was talking about feelings and that I just feel God’s love right now.
[25:05] Five years before I would have just heard that more cliché and trite but now that I’m inside the grammar of the restored gospel that’s significant when you say you feel something that you’re sensing that God is there and he’s communicating to us and he says that divine things, sacred things happen in in this office and then we had this time where we were just we began to cry. I wouldn’t have done that in a bishop or pastor’s office probably years ago but there was something that I just felt that that there was that thin place between us and heaven and it was right there in that office. And I’ve used this phrase but I’ve ripped it off of other theologians but it fits very well in the restored gospel. I feel like I belonged before I believed and it was a very embodied belonging, a very physical connection. I remember going over to award um dinner after I’d kind of made some visits here. I was collaborating with different scholars and just being in I mean it was it was if I was I already knew these people. It was just weird. I just feel like I struck up a conversation but I’d never met these people. And one could argue that maybe because pre-mortally I knew them uh but I just felt that there was this there was this connection with them.
I love how you talked about this thin place right and it strikes me that this idea of a thin place Latter-day Saints often talk about the veil being very thin in certain places and circumstances. That’s a wonderful kind of working informal definition of what we mean by sacramental, a place where the veil is thin and God’s glory and divinity are apparent and are making themselves manifest. I also this idea of of belonging before believing. And how our embodied practices make that visible and in fact bring it into being. One of the things I love about our sacrament meetings as as chaotic as they can be, um I love that we pass the sacrament trays to each other. I don’t know where you were sitting on the first time that you that you um experienced a Latter-day Saint sacrament meeting, but it’s likely that if you were sitting somewhere in the middle of the pew, you yourself received the trail tray and passed it on. You yourselves belonged to that chain of passing the body and blood amongst the body of Christ. That’s one sort of very small but very concrete way in which our belongingness, our unity as the body of Christ is is concretized in these in these physical practices. So little by little through experiences of the sacred grove, through experiences with Latter-day Saints, becoming more familiar with Latter-day Saint practices of worship, um your your body and thus your spirit because as we’ve established they’re one in the same, is coming closer to um a kind of full a moment of full commitment and full ongoing inclusion. Tell us now about your baptism. Of all the ordinances, um baptism may be the most viscerally embodied, right? You’re you’re immersed, you can’t breathe for a moment, you’re very vulnerable. You through immersion you have to completely put yourself at the mercy of the one who baptizes you. There are so many ways that we can think about baptism as an embodied moment, but talk to us about about baptism.
[28:05] Good good another good question. So let me just back up real quick. I was just thinking when I referenced earlier as far as my tradition before coming uh fully into the restored gospel, I often found myself when we would receive we would call the Eucharist, uh any type of you know kind of sacramental imagination only took me so far and it always pointed to something that was bodiless. The father didn’t have a body, right? In that worldview. And so I feel like the beauty of the restored gospel is that now this bodily experience is more of less of a window and more of a conduit, right? It’s the body that I have is the same stuff that the father has, uh, physicality. So when I think about the sacramental imagination, I I’m not I’m not retracting that at all. In fact, if anything, it’s more robust in the restored gospel. And so if something like baptism, I mean it is. It’s it’s it was it’s so physical. Um, I taking on the name of Christ. Again, here I am feeling like I’m encircled in the very arms of love, uh, that, um, people are talking over me. Uh, people are, um, naming the very experience I’m having and then the, you know, the confirmation service as well. It’s very physical then the, you know, people came up as far as encircled me as far as the confirmation. Again, and I liked what you said. There’s a social corporal body always with the individual body. That’s part of my background before I became in the Episcopalian was more of this, um, evangelical, which at times can be very kind of a personal individual soteriology. So I think the beauty of the restored gospel is more collective, more corporate. And so the baptism experience, it’s what enrolled me into the church. It’s what be it’s how I became a member of the church. And so that whole experience with even the the talks around that, everything was very it was you know, it was auditory. It was it was it was just a very substantive experience that pointed back to my body with other bodies in corporation with with with with with the Godhead, with the with the father.
I have to know, John, were you, um, were you baptized in a stake center in a sort of conventional font? Wonderful. Did you wear the polyester jumpsuit?
I I That’s what they’re made out of. Yeah, I did. I I love that too. Just the, you know, as far as what that symbolizes, uh, as far as the holiness, the new life and I’m you know, I’m invited into this this covenant path that begins with baptism. Well, with faith, repentance, and baptism, but yeah.
Yeah. There’s so many distinctive and and endearing little details about a conventionally Latter-day Saint baptismal service. Of course, Latter-day Saints can be baptized in many different settings, and oftentimes these services can look quite different, but there’s something very beautiful about the liturgy, the sort of folk liturgy that has sprung up around baptism with the talks about baptism, about the Holy Ghost, and then this beautiful choreography. Who Who baptized you?
[31:11] Matt Seely. Thanks to Matt Seely.
Wonderful. So was he a friend?
Yeah, so he was a part of the journey early on. And so that’s another thing, too. When I started meeting with the missionaries, the first meeting I said I I’ve been converted and need to be baptized, but I said I got to catch here. I want to be baptized in Utah. And so they I had to get permission to do that, but it wasn’t a big deal because this is where my journey really started with the folks here. And I felt like there’s just a significant cohort of people who have prayed with me. I mean, I used to send out emails, and it was a chain email that went to all these people that prayed for me as I was transitioning because I knew the consequences of my decision I would lose my job at Baylor.
Yeah. Yeah, you undertook this with the greatest of discernment and seriousness, both because of its meaning in spiritually, but also because of the significant professional and personal consequences. And I know that you’ve taken each step deliberately and with the guidance of the Spirit and with great courage as well, John. I I recognize that and appreciate it.
And I wanted to get this right. So I I I’ve shared this with you, Roslyn, because I shared it with colleagues here. Early on, this investigation I was more like Nicodemus going to Jesus because I wasn’t sure where this was going to go. So I didn’t tell a lot of people because what if it what if it results in me not converting? So I was like I don’t want to alarm anyone. But I said if if they because it was still they then if they don’t get Jesus right, I’m not in. And so this is the scandal I think of the incarnation and putting together kind of the the architecture of the worldview that I’ve now taken on wholeheartedly. So, the incarnation, you see this turn to the body that occurred in the 20th century, but the incarnation predated that turn to the body, that Jesus Christ that took on a human body, but this was the intended end from the beginning because the father had a body. And so this is this is the beauty of the protology and the teleology, right? That most Christian traditions think body just began, right, at creation, and then Jesus became embodied, right, took on humanity. Um and and Tertullian even says this that this that that the flesh is the hinge of salvation, but that that flesh is something that the father is composed of flesh and bones as we see in DNC. And so God has a face. And so all those things were significant. So, again, all the precursor to this and me studying the theology of the body, I didn’t realize how rich this is as far as the materiality in the restored gospel.
Yeah. Once you have an understanding of not only God the Son, right, Jesus Christ, but God the Father himself as an embodied experiential being who can be in real loving relationship with us, suddenly all the work you had done previously on embodiment, on sacramentality, on incarnation, suddenly this kind of glows with a new light and new significance from the inside.
Yeah, I mean, I would have never guessed that that stuff I was studying was going to find further fulfillment and just I mean, I did it out of a passion because of some stuff that happened to me when I was a young kid with my body.
[34:14] And so I didn’t realize that all this it’s just I can’t explain it without God. So.
I like you um find some of my moments of greatest joy and euphoria in contemplating the the word of God in scripture and in appreciating the the brilliance and simplicity and depthlessness of the restored gospel that Joseph Smith revealed. Um, I stand in awe when I read the Book of Mormon. Um, I try to get to the bottom of that thing. I I don’t think I will ever find it. It constantly reveals new layers of meaning. Um, for me that is an incredibly enlivening experience. But it can be again you and I we’re academics, we’re intellectuals. Um, it can sort of exist up here in our head. Um, and the thing about being up here in our head is that that can be hard to share with other people. Now, thank goodness for language and communication, right?
Through language and communication we can share this together and you can share your experience with me in a way that so deeply moving to me. But still what we think originates and and for the most part it kind of stays in our heads. Um, so I want you now to reflect not only on how your understanding has grown in the months since your baptism, but how has your embodiment changed? We we sort of started out tracing one kind of a journey from a a sort of deadening experience of the body to a sacramentally alive experience of the body. Then we traced the kind of coming alive of your conversion to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. In the last several months, what have you noticed about what it’s been like to live live as John an embodied John White in this 50 some year old body that you have?
I’m only 40.
Uh, you know so I took on the word of wisdom um obviously towards the end of my uh missionary meetings. Um, but a year before that I because I saw some just habits in my life that I was concerned about. My father was an alcoholic. I decided to give up drinking about 8 to 10 months for the word of wisdom. So one of the things I recognized the word of wisdom if I really care about the integrity and dig personal dignity in my body, the word of wisdom actually is a spiritual practice that corresponds to that metaphysic of the body. And so an argument that I would want to make is that the word of wisdom shows that this dwelling is substantively good, and I would want to treat this dwelling well as a temple of God. And so, that’s the those are the kind of things that I’m starting to think about more. Um, it’s amazing the things that I sacrificed. Um, my wife’s grandmother once said that anything that’s truly worthy or worth something, it’ll cost you something. So, it costs me, but I don’t think about that cost that much because I feel like it’s just this is just the this is just what you do. Just kind of on a theoretical level, definitely that’s enhanced my view of the body. Um, but then also living here in Utah, I I I go for walks. Uh, my routines are such that you even said this earlier, Rosalind. There’s this kinship that we have with the environment, with nature. And that’s another thing that’s beautiful about just materiality as understood in the restored gospel. And so, even though the tree is not me, um, there’s there’s a there’s a relationship that I can have with those when I’m out for a walk. And so, I start to I feel like I have eyes to see and ears to hear that I didn’t before. There’s maybe some things that were muted because I didn’t have the companionship of the Holy Spirit. Not not some things there were. So, I have the companionship of the Holy Spirit, so I can attend to those things in my body more closely. I find myself coming to church.
I I have a journal. I I didn’t do that before. I’m always writing down something, some line. This is where I brought some of my Protestant tradition. We talked about have you ever heard of a lectio divina reading? But I do the whole sacrament meaning lectio divina where I’m trying to listen like some I I attach to some phrase or some idea, write that down. Sometimes I go back and revisit, sometimes I don’t because I feel like in the moment it was exactly. And so, it’s just keeping me focused. So, I would say that’s helping me to connect myself to the meetings and to the fellowship that I experience in those meetings.
I really appreciate the way you talked about, um, your journey with the word of wisdom. And I want to acknowledge that for um, many converts to give up beloved family practices around wine or other things is a real sacrifice. For those of us who didn’t grow up with it, it can be hard, I think, to understand that it’s so much more than any sort of a physical sensation. It’s a ritual and it’s a practice.
There’s meaning associated with that.
there’s meaning there.
And one would one could argue good meaning, right? It’s not all bad.
It’s not all bad. It’s not. To you, I I see that sacrifice. I recognize it, and I think many people out there will also recognize that. But I think the sort of journey that you came to truly own um your observance of the Word of Wisdom is so important. As long as we experience the Word of Wisdom as restrictions that are put on us, that can be a place to start. But I think we only come into full maturity when we begin to understand and observe the Word of Wisdom intrinsically, right? And integrally. Um and from the basis of our bodies and and in full faith that we can have the sort of fullness of human experience in a body that is observing the Word of Wisdom. And when we sort of approach it from that positive, hopeful, um and adventurous basis, right? I want to see what it’s like. What is it going to be like to live so fully into my body? I think then we we come to a mature observance of the Word of Wisdom.
I like that cuz I think freedom is both negative and positive. And perhaps at first when people begin to observe and practice the Word of Wisdom, it’s more of a negative, what I cannot do or should not do, right? Instead of seeing, well, there’s a positive freedom here. This is actually if we understand what Paul says that um that the Lord owns your body and it’s been purchased with a price, aren’t you going to want to use that body in such a way that glorifies God? I think that then opens us up to all the positive experiences and perhaps ways of coping in the past uh that were not not all destructive, but they may have been limiting instead of more freeing. So we we physically want to live well so that we can steward these bodies in such a way that maximize the very presence of God in our lives.
[40:57] I want to steward my body in such a way that maximizes the presence of God in my life. I love that. I want to write that down and and put it up in my in my office and in my kitchen. Maybe as we start to draw our conversation to a close, I wanted to ask you about what I think is actually the most um body positive aspect of Latter-day Saint theology. And that is growing out of this um you know Joseph Smith’s revelation that that God is is is an embodied person, but it’s slightly different. That is um our practice of proxy ordinances. It seems to me that the way in which we can truly give our body as a gift for the spiritual redemption of another person is one of the most profoundly positive endorsements of the goodness of the body that that I can really imagine.
And it’s it occurred to me reading your article on sports as a kind of sacrament that there might be insights from that idea that can be applied to this idea of our proxy ordinances. So I’d love to hear what you make of Latter-day Saint temple baptisms. How does that fit into a sacramental framework? Um and what is your theological knowledge what light does it shed on on that practice that we share?
Yeah, that’s a good question. In fact, I’m working on two papers. Um working hasn’t just starting. Uh but one of the things that I thought about uh just as you’re talking there this is an opportunity for us to serve and bless them through um these these these proxy uh uh baptisms, these ordinances, right? So as you play sports, think about all the intrinsic goods, whether it be camaraderie, whether it be just learning to have uh more enchanted relationship with your body, uh this notion of play. Those are all things that are internal uh to to sports. And the same thing with education, right? go to school to get a job, but that’d be extrinsic. Now, I know if parents are listening, I’m not saying you don’t go to school to get a job, but there’s just learning to think critically, learning to write well.
Those are goods that are intrinsic to it. And so it seems like one of the goods is intrinsic to this baptism of the for the dead is that it’s a it’s a gift to them. It seems to be intrinsically good to this practice. And and again, they still have their agency. They still need to choose this, but they wouldn’t have this opportunity if you didn’t do that for them. And so I guess um kind of the the logic of gift continues even after death.
Yeah, it strikes me that in some ways the the the practice of baptism for the dead of proxy ordinances sort of takes to its logical fulfillment the doctrines of theological anthropology and the incarnation itself. If we understand that we have a body for the same purpose that Jesus did, right? Jesus came and and took on flesh and blood as we did in order to reveal who God is to the world and then to perform his atoning sacrifice, right? To make the gift of salvation available to us, we understand our own bodies as having those same functions, right? We too are here in the world to manifest divinity, right? To find those thin places and to do as Jesus would do to make God’s hands visible in the world. And as part of that, we can channel in some small portion the grace that originates in the sacrifice of Jesus Christ. We can open these little channels and let that grace flow through to other people. We can be small S saviors on Mount Zion as we tend to say. Um never, you know, um usurping the the supreme role of Jesus and his sacrifice, but making the grace that flows from that available um here on Earth precisely through the gift of our bodies in the same way that Jesus did. We lay down our bodies for the good of others and then pick it up again in a consecrated way.
That the flesh is the hinge of salvation in the same way our bodies here are the hinge of proclaiming salvation through the baptism of the dead. Recognizing that ultimately the atonement is the object of that and Jesus is the one who brings the healing and the salvation, but we’re we’re as you said we’re we’re we’re mediums of that. We’re we’re conduits of that, channels of that. I like that.
of that grace. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I think that image of our bodies as channels of divine grace that flows through us and beyond us towards others, binding us together in this belonging in the body of Christ. That’s a perfect way to end a wonderful conversation. John White, thank you for joining me today on the Maxwell Institute podcast.
Thank you, Russell.