Do We Ever Really Get Out of Anarchy?
| Author | Alfred G. Cuzán |
|---|---|
| Published | 1979 |
| Format | Research paper |
| Original | Read the original |
TL;DR — Cuzán argues that government never ends anarchy, it only moves it inside the ruling group, so the real question is which kind of anarchy is least violent.
Alfred G. Cuzán, of New Mexico State University’s Department of Government, wrote this short essay for the Journal of Libertarian Studies (vol. 3, no. 2, 1979). He takes on the libertarian debate between anarchists and minimal-state advocates and argues it skips a prior question: whether anyone can leave anarchy at all.
His answer is no. A government forces citizens to accept it as a “third party” in their disputes, but nobody stands as a third party over the rulers themselves; congressmen, judges and bureaucrats settle their conflicts by maneuver and pressure, which he likens to vigilante justice. Society therefore always lives in some anarchy, either market anarchy or political anarchy, and political anarchy comes in hierarchical and plural forms.
He then argues, with a few simple diagrams and examples rather than data, that pluralist systems (Switzerland, India, Costa Rica) are less violent than hierarchical ones (the Soviet Union, China, Cuba), possibly because centralized rulers make more mistakes and must enforce them by force. He ends by asking whether market anarchy might be less violent still. The acknowledgments thank Murray Rothbard and Walter Block, and the notes cite Tullock, Bakunin and Speer.
What it is: A short theoretical essay in a libertarian academic journal. It argues by analogy and offers its comparisons of violence across countries as observations, not measurements.
Where this came from
- Will Manidis’s “most underrated PDF” thread, July 2023 — routing record: The Most Underrated PDF on the Internet (July 2023)
8 pages. A copy is archived locally against link rot; the header links the original source.