An Economic Interpretation of the Word of Wisdom (Leonard J. Arrington)
| Author | Leonard J. Arrington |
|---|---|
| Published | 1959 |
| Format | Article |
| Original | Read the original |
The Word of Wisdom was treated as good advice for its first three decades and became a test of loyalty after 1867, because a cash-poor, isolated Utah could not afford to send its gold and silver east for tea, coffee and tobacco.
An Economic Interpretation of the Word of Wisdom (Leonard J. Arrington)
The essay ran in the first issue of BYU Studies and is the article that, per Leonard Arrington and the Writing of Mormon History, drew a complaint that had Arrington told to write a letter of apology. Arrington presents it “not as a ‘final’ interpretation, but only as a contribution” to a sensitive and seldom-studied phase of Utah history.
Key claims
- The puzzle. Latter-day Saints were once known mainly for their group economic, political and social life and “peculiar” beliefs, yet by the twentieth century were known chiefly for not using liquor, tobacco, tea and coffee. Arrington argues an important contributing cause was economic.
- Two existing origin theories. One ties the February 27, 1833 Kirtland revelation to specific local problems; Brigham Young recounts the School of the Prophets meeting over Joseph Smith’s kitchen in a cloud of pipe smoke, and Emma Smith’s complaints about the floor. The other, from Dean D. McBrien, reads it as a distillation of the temperance wave; the Kirtland Temperance Society (organized October 6, 1830, 239 members) closed the Kirtland distillery on February 1, 1833, twenty-seven days before the revelation.
- Early practice was mixed. Kirtland and Far West councils (1834, 1837) made observance a test for holding office or fellowship, and David Whitmer’s trial listed non-observance first among five charges. Yet across the 1830s and 1840s many treated it as advice; Joseph Smith’s journal records wine at weddings and with his mother in 1836, and Brigham Young did not make it a test of fellowship.
- The turn came in 1867. That year the Women’s Relief Society and the men’s School of the Prophets were organized in each community, and both adopted rules requiring observance.
- The economic logic. More than 1,500 miles from the States, Utah needed a self-sufficient economy and had few ways to earn cash. Spending scarce dollars on imported “Bull Durham, Battle-Axe plugs, tea, coffee” worked against the territory. Young therefore objected less to locally grown tobacco and developed a local “Mormon” tea.
- The railroad made it urgent. To avoid absorption into the national free-trading economy, the territory took the transcontinental construction contract for outside income, launched the cooperative movement, and pared consumer imports “to the bone”; Word of Wisdom emphasis after 1867 was “an essential part” of that third step.
- The numbers Young used. He estimated at least $60,000 a year left the territory for tobacco alone, citing William H. Hooper’s sales of over $28,000 a year; he said the silver and gold spent on tobacco “would have built several extensive cotton and woolen factories.”
- Wine fits the same pattern. Dixie wine was made partly for the sacrament (wine was used until as late as 1897) but mainly as an export to mining towns to bring in cash; more was drunk locally than intended and the enterprise ended before 1900.
- From necessity to principle. By the 1880s abstinence had become a loyalty test taught to the young, with widespread pledges; by the late 1890s Lorenzo Snow could suggest the revelation was violated as much by eating meat. After 1900 the emphasis rose further, sustained by institutionalization and by medical research popularized by John A. Widtsoe and Leah Widtsoe.
Notable quotes
“Economic interpretations are almost always inadequate and one-sided, but they frequently offer helpful insights into historical processes and their causation.”
“Utah had no Marshall Plan on which to rely for the solution of her chronic shortage of dollars; she could not maintain consumption as usual and still build up her productive power in the way that was necessary to provide jobs for the never-ending streams of converts coming to Zion to dwell.”
“It was consistent with the economics of the time that he should have had no great objection to tobacco chewing if the tobacco was grown locally.”
“The silver and gold which we have paid out for this article alone, since we first came into Utah, would have built several extensive cotton and woolen factories, and filled them with machinery.” (Brigham Young, quoted)
“Some of the brethern are very strenuous upon the ‘Word of Wisdom,’ and would like to have me preach upon it, and urge it upon the brethren, and make it a test of fellowship. I do not think that I shall do so. I have never done so.” (Brigham Young, 1867, quoted)
“A matter of economic necessity had been converted into a principle of religious faith.”
“For reasons of faith, loyalty, and good health, therefore, the faithful Latter-day Saint still observes the Word of Wisdom.”
How it connects
- Leonard Arrington and the Writing of Mormon History describes this article as the one that set off the complaint chain Arrington later cited (“I write an article on the Word of Wisdom. Someone complains…”), a case study in the line between hagiography and reductionism. The Word of Wisdom page summarises it from that book; this is the article itself.
- Brigham Young — Pioneer Prophet describes the same oscillation between “forced abstinence” and latitude, with strict enforcement only late in Young’s life. Arrington supplies the economic reason for the timing.
- Capital allocation at the scale of a territory. The argument is an import-substitution story: a closed economy short of hard currency rations consumer imports to fund capital goods, with church organizations as the enforcement mechanism. The same self-sufficiency story is the subject of Arrington’s Great Basin Kingdom, which Working Toward Zion reports the Manila area presidency read to learn how the pioneers raised their standard of living.
Archived privately against link rot: ../attachments/an-economic-interpretation-of-the-word-of-wisdom/An_Economic_Interpretation_of_the_Word_of_Wisdom.pdf (the BYU Studies PDF; the ScholarsArchive copy is behind a Cloudflare check).